#$%
#! &'( )#$ #*
+ ,.-(/10 /123/1465785
9:78;=<1>@?A0 7B5C?D1EFGDC0 ;IHJ?K78>MLJNO4P7B5NQ7
RS5I4UTC78>VW4U?YX D1E%Z[D785VWHIH
\ ]
>DC^I2_780 `a^=<[VK78b 2_7c<1>d5I465e 0 7f?WgDJb
\
9:7hViNO>d46;J?W4_DC5D1Ej?Wg7%NQDCH>kVl7nmaoMg7hDC>7Q?W46N8<12CpJDCHI5`
b=<q?W4_DC5VrD1E$FGDC0 ;IH)?i78>nLNh4_785INf7fmstoupFMLIvwsx?Ag7f`
DC> XyD1E.NfDC0 ;IHJ?z<1^I46264{?@X|v*465 ;I>DC^I2_780 `a^=<[VK78b~}S<hX
\
T<126H|<q?A4_DC5 D1E?Ag7y>7OViHI2U?KV
I t t)HVW45ey;>kDC^I2P7B0 VB1H78>l4P7OVDC>;IHJOB2_7hV
<[V(Vk?<1>@?W465e ;DC465C?EDC>2_7c<1>l5465e
5 E<1N?T<1>d4_7f?@X D1E<1;;I>kDj<1Nzg7hVBj7C,e=,
26264PV <12,6
,Cc= ¡)¢ £i n=¤h I¥¥B.¦§¨ 5DC>l0 <122_78Nz`
?AH>k7hVB:^IH)? ;I>DC^I2_780 V <1>7 HVl78b ?iD 0 D1?W4UT<q?K7
Vd?WHIb785C?KV:<15Ib b780 DC5Vk?A>K<q?K7?Wg7?Ag7hDC>@X",
©
,ª « t¬ ¥B ¡)¢ £K r=¤Q) ¡) t%;I>DC^)`
2_780 V<1>k7 VKDC2{TC7Bb 465 ?Wg7ye">DCHI;VBI^IHJ?<12_VlD 2_78Nz`
?AH>k7hV <1>7 HVK78b ?iD ;I>7hVK785C?y?Ag7 EtHI5Ib=<10 785C?z<12
NfDC5INf7B;)?iV<15Ib®NQDC5NQ78;J?WH=<1262{X0 DVk?bI4U¯ NhHI2{?$?KDC;)`
46NfVB,
°
,C±«¬¡¡(¥¬c= ¡¢ £K n=¤h ¡Iq¬ t¬(;I>DC^I2_780 V
e"HI46b7 <15Ib b>l4UTC7 ?Wg7 785C?W46>7 2P7q<1>d5I465Je 7³²;78>l4´`
785INf7C,
\ ¹
Nºj5Dc}u2_78be»780 785C?wD1E2P7q<1>d578>VB¼J7²I;78>d4_785INf7C,
\ 0 ;g=<[VW4_VDC5 Vk?AHb785C?iV½?z<1º465Je >7hVW;DC5VW46^I4264U?@X
D1E?Wg7846>½Dc}u5 2_7c<1>d5I465e=,
\
F½>kDVlVW465Je D1E^=DCHI5Ib=<1>d4_7hVw^7f?Y}7h785 bI4_ViNO4;I264657hV8,
\
pJDJNhHVDC5 ?Wg7®;I>DJNf7OVlVK7hVwD1Enº5Dc}u2_78be»7¾<1NhHI4{`
VW4U?W4_DC5 >K<q?Ag7B>n?Wg=<15 ?Wg7:;I>kD)bIHIN?iVD1E$VWHNg ;I>kD¸`
Nf7OVlVK7hVB,
\
F½g=<15e»7 465 Vd?z<q¿ >DC2_7 E>DC0 465Vd?W>lHIN?KDC>®?iD E<c`
Nh462643<q?KDC>h,
\
Lj?WHIb785C?:VK782UEx`M<15b ;7h78><[VlVK7hVKVi0 785C?(D1E2_7c<1>l5)`
465e=,
\
pJDJNhHVMDC5 NQDC0 0 HI5I46N8<q?W4_DC5 <15Ib 465C?i78>d;78>VKDC5=<12
VWº4262_VB,
\
oMg7Vd?WHIb785C?KVwg=<hTC7b7h78;78>¨HI5Ib7B>Vd?z<15IbI45e D1E
?Ag7 4_VKViH7hV
\ Ä
7f?d?i78>M0 D1?W4UT<q?W4_DC5
\
0 ;I>kDcTC7hV NfDC0 0 HI546N8<q?A4_DC5 <15Ib NfDDC;78>K<q?A4_DC5
VWº4262_V
\
0 ;I>kDcTC7hV 0 7f?z<1NfDÅe"5I4U?W4UTC7 VWº4262_V 2646º17 ;I>DC^I2_780
VKDC2UT465e <15Ib }(<hXJVMD1E¬?WgI465Iºj465e=,
\
5bI4UT46bH=<12G2_7c<1>l5I45e e»Dj<12_V VWHI;;DC>@? bI4U¿Æ78>k785C?
2_7c<1>l57B>V~sÇ<12_VKD ;DDC>Vk?AHIb7B5C?KVG0 <15|<e»7S}½78262Ã45
]ĽÈ
v
\ É
4UTC7hV ;I>K<1N³?W4_Vl7 45 >k7hVK7c<1>dNg <15Ib 465JEÊDC>d0 <q?W4_DC5
>k7f?W>l4P7QT<12
Ë~¤h¥)¦Å tI¡¡xÌ ¤8« x·c| ¡ Ía| ¦Å.¢ ¥n«·8C ¤8¦Å )¦Å!Î
¶
B x·B t¦»I¡ Ñ!«)¤³·8 Ã¨Ò 9:D ?Ag7 Vd?WHIb785C?KV <1NhHI46>7
<[V®e»DDJb ?Ag7hDC>7f?A46N8<12º5Dc}u2_78be»7 <[V¾465 ?Wg7 ?A>K<1bI4{`
?A4_DC5|<12!78bIHIN8<q?W4_DC5Ó
Ô )¤Q)¦§)¤Ò
\
0 0 78bI43<q?K7B2{X <qEÕ?K78>?Wg7 NQDCH>kVl7 ?Wg7 ;I>DC^I2_780 `
^=<[VK78b 2_7c<1>l578>Vrg|<OTC7¨^7f?l?K78>¬Viº46262PV^IHJ?VW24Pe"gC?A2{X
;DDC>78>Mº5Dc}u2_78be»7?Ag|<15 ?A>K<1bI4U?W4_DC5=<12!2_7c<1>d578>kV
\ Ö D VW4Pe"54U×N8<15C?ØbI4U¿Æ7B>785INf7(465 º5Dq}u2P7BbJe»7S2_7fTC782
7fTC7B5 ^=7Q?d?K7B>>k7hVWH2U?iV:g=<hTC7¾^7h785 >k78;DC>@?K7Bb$,
\ ¹
EÕ?K78>~VKDC0 7 ?A40 7 ?Ag7 ?Wg7hDC>7Q?W46N8<12nºj5Dc}u2_78be»7
D1E
]ĽÈ
2_7c<1>l578>V 4_V <q? 2_7c<[Vd? e»DDJb <[V ?A>K<1bI4{`
?A4PDC5=<12Ø2_7c<1>d578>kV¾Ù 4,Ú7», ?Wg7
]ĽÈ
2P7q<1>d578>V >7³`
0 780 ^78>w^7f?l?K78>G}ug=<q?M?Wg7fX g=<hTC72_7c<1>d5C?c,
Û
¦Åä³·8q«¦¸·8 x t¤f·Â CÜ =Í¡) t¬¬Ò?Ag7GVk?AH)`
b785C?iV%<1N?W4UTC782UX NfDC5Vd?W>dHIN?n?Wg7846>nº5Dq}u2P7BbJe»7½DC5 ?Wg7
^=<[VW4_VMD1E?Wg7846>½Dc}u5 7³²;78>l4P7B5NQ7 <15Ib >k7fÝI7BN?W4_DC5V
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun Mon Tue Wed exercise session
new topic
Thu Fri Sat Sun Mon Tue Wed
Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun Mon Tue Wed
introduced
topic is exercise
session
Thu Fri Sat Sun Mon
new problems
new topic reports are returned
the problems and diaries feedback about
new problems
new topic reports are returned
feedback about the problems and diaries reports are returned
problems are opened and discussed
Thu Fri Sat Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun Mon :
Problem−based method Traditional method
introduced topic is
ßKàâáÕãÇäæå
ÕçQè
å6éxäëêàâêÇá"ìäëíî_åïëïcàâêð´ä´éòñàóðæàâíÕêôéòõéxêñIìÇäæíÕöõóå÷øùöôéòïæåñ÷Cå_ð´úÇíñ û8üíxõâàâñ
õâàâêÇåqñåïëîäæàóöYå_ïOéxî_ðæàóýÕåìäëíî_åïëïæàâêÇájéxêÇñúéxïæúõâàóêåqìôéxïëïæàóýxåìäæítîå_ïæïæàóêáû
þ Ü ·8 .«=Æ·8" ¤8«¦»¦Å)¤O¤Ð
\ + 7B22{`ÿVk?A>dHIN?AH>k78b~;I>kDC^2_780 VÆEÊDC>!5DcT46Nf7Vd?WHIb785C?KVB
DC;785)`ô7B5b78b <15Ib 46262{`ôVd?W>lHN³?WHI>78b ;I>DC^I2_780 VEÊDC>
<1bJT<15INf78b Vd?WHIb785C?KVB,
\ È
7c<1>l5I45e bI4 <1> X g7826;V ?iD NfDC5Vk?A>dHIN? DcTC78>i<1262
;I46N?WHI>k7hVu<15Ib ViHI;I;=DC> ?KV½?Wg7y2_7c<1>d5I465e ;I>DJNf7hVKV8,
&'( M#$ #*
\ °
NOH NfDCHI>VK7<1^=DCHJ??Wg7Ø?Wg7hDC> X D1E.NfDC0 ;HJ?<1^462{`
4U?@X
\
g 2_78N?AH>k7hVB
© g 7²78>dNh4_VK7Vl7hVKVW4PDC5V
\
Vk?AHb785C?iV^7Qe<15 ?Ag7 NfDCHI>VK7 s
°
;I>DC^I2_780 `
^=<[VK78b }S<hXj
B©
?A>K<1bI4U?W4_DC5=<123v
\
2_78N³?WHI>78>
©
<[VKVW4PVd?z<15C?iV sÕ?K7c<1Ng465e 7²78>dNO4PVK7
VK7hVKVi4_DC5Vzv
¶
.÷q=¦¸· K·8)=¦§¬ tÒ
\
<1^DCHJ?
©
gDCHI>VS2_78N?WHI>k7hV
\
?@}½D gDCHI>V ;I>DC^I2_780 VKDC2{T465e <1NhNQDC>dbI465Je ?KD
`
Vd?K78; 0 DJb782
\ ©
gDCH>kV7²78>dNh4_VK7Vl7hVKVW4PDC5V
þ .¢ »Ü |¤Ò
\
VK782UEx`ôVd?WHIbJX 465JEÊDC>d0 <q?W4_DC5 NfDC262_78N?A45e
\
}u>l4{?A465Je ;I>DC^I2_780 >78;DC>@?iV
\
}u>l4{?A465Je 2_7c<1>d5I465e bI43<1>@X
\
VKDC2UT465e 7³²7B>dNh4_VK7~?<[Viº"V
·c·8 t¤f·8 t¦»¤»Ò
]ĽÈ
o>K<1b , ?KD1?z<12
^7Qe<15 ?Ag7NfDCHI>kVl7 ° B©
bI>kDC;;78b
s v s
v B©
;=<[VKVl7Bb
s!
© v s
v °
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16
1- 1 1+ 2- 2 2+ 3- 3
3.6%
12.5%
10.7%
14.3%
21.4%
10.7%
5.4%
19.6%
problem-based way
ßKàóáÕãäëå µç$# úåáÕä´éòñåñàâï ð´äæàóöãÇðæàâíÕêí&%KìäëíÕöõóå÷øùöôéxïëåñJõâåéxäæêÇåäæï_û
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16
1- 1 1+ 2- 2 2+ 3- 3
14.3% 28.6%
14.3% 14.3% 28.6%
traditional way
ßKàóáÕãäëå ÀÇç$# úå[áÕä´éòñåqñàâï ð´äëàâöãÇðæàâíÕê)í&%lðæä´éxñàð´àóíÕêôéxõaõâåéxäæêå_äæï_û
FGDCHI>kVl7¾7fT<126H=<q?W4_DC5 EÊDC>d0 VB
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
vs qs n qu
17%
69%
8% 6%
satisfaction with the course
ßKàâáÕãÇäæå Ï ç)# úåï ð´ãñå_êð´ï+*kí ýÕå_ä´éxõóõKïæéòð´àóï,% éxîPð´àâíxê.-hàóðæúIð´úåÅî_íÕãäëïæå/ýtï10Býxåä,2Iï´éòðæàâï ø
3 åñ5476Êï1086Êãàð´åï´éòðæàâï 3 åñ54ôê90qêÇíÕäæ÷"éxõ:46Êã7086tãÇàóð´åãêÇï´éòðæàâï 3 åñ7;Uû
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
vs qs qu
61%
31%
8%
satisfaction with PBL
ßKàâáÕãÇäæå Þç<# úå³ï ð´ãñå_êð´ï+*òï´éòðæàâï=%éxî_ðæàâíÕê>-hàóðæú¸ð´úÇå@?BA è ÷Cå_ð´úÇíñ/ ýtï10Býxåä,21ï´éòðæàâï 3 åñ54
6tïC086tãÇàóð´å[ï´é ð´àâï
3
åñD4ôê70cêíÕäæ÷"éxõE46Êã7086Êãàóðæåãêï´é ð´àâï
3
åñ9;Pû
Lj?AHb785C?iV8¼jEÊ7h7Bb^=<1Nº 465 2P7q<1>d5I465Je b43<1>l4P7OV8
\
Lj?WHIb785C?iV2_7c<1>l5C?(^7f?l?K78>
\
oMg7fX }½78>7y^7f?d?i78>0 D1?A4UT<q?K78b
\
oMg7fX ^=78264_7fTC78b ?Wg7fX }u46262 >k780 780 ^78>G2_DC5e»78>
\
pJDC>k784Pe"578>GVd?WHIb785C?iVw}78>7y0 DC>7y<10 ^I4UT<12_785C?
Ï
\ H
DC>k7®?Wg=<15 DC57?AHJ?KDC>VWgDCHI26b ^7 <OT<1423<1^I2_7 45
;I>DC^I2_780 Vl7OVlVW4_DC5VGI sLHee»7hVd?W4_DC5
?WHJ?KDC>$J
© `
©
Vk?AHIb7B5C?KVv
\ ¹
VKVi4_Vd?z<15C?KVB¼C}½DC>dº <10 DCHI5C?%}S<[VMHI4{?i7~5DC>d0 <12
^IHJ?:2P7BN?WHI>7B>Q¼ÚV}½DC>dº }S<[VM785DCHI>d0 DCHV
\
F½g78Nºj465e(;I>DC^I2_780 >k78;=DC> ?KV¬<15b¾>7q<1b465e(2_7c<1>d5)`
465e:bI4 <1>l4_7hV*?<1º17%^=D1?Ag<1^DCHJ?
` 0 465KJVk?AHIb7B5C?
}½7O78º2{Xj,
\
o¬7c<1Nzg78>kV <e">7O78b ?Ag=<q? Vk?AHIb7B5C?KV VK7h780 78b ?KD
2_7c<1>l5 ^=7Q?d?K7B>(<15b }½78>7y>7q<122UX 0 D1?A4UT<q?K78b ,
\
5MLYDqX)<1^2_7 <12PVKD EÊDC>w?Ag7~?K7q<1Nzg78>VGI
\ ¹
TC78> X VWHINhNf7hVdEHI22=7²I;=7B>d460 785C?®stH=<15C?W4U?YX <15Ib
H=<1264{?@X|v
\ ]
>DcTC7Bb ?Wg=<q?
]ĽÈ
VWHI4{?iV}½7B22|<12_VlD®EÊDC>?Wg7?Ag7f`
DC>k7f?W46N8<12 NfDCHI>VK7hVD1ErNfV
\ ]ĽÈ
4_V }½DC>@?Ag D1E 45CTC7OVk?A45e 0 DC>k7 Vk?<q¿ >7³`
VKDCHI>dNf7hV
\ + 7 >k78NfDC0 0 785Ib }S<1>l0 2UXNI
R PS T U
PV WP
U
[ \^]_` acb ] d
egf h
` ikj lmj no j pd
` ]q pb j p`r s t \
` _ s
o u
` j s
_ d
b b v w
bq pb j p`r s
_yx z \l p \ ]q` o j pd
` ]q ] j u s
q{
sb u
` ikj
` s \
`| f
}
f h
` ikj lmj n
r q b ~d
`| t \
` _ s
o u
` j s
_ u l
_ p
o _ _ ] ~bo s s \
` r q b ~d
`| f
f
q ] lmj _ sbq| lmj n s
o u
` j s
_ s
q{ sb pb j_
s
q o p s
x s
` _ s ] j u pb
| r ]q` ul
` q` j s
\
{r b s \
` _ l
_ ] j u
` r d] j ] slb j_
f
f cb j_
s
q o p s lmj n \ {r
b s \
` _` _ t \
` r q b ~d
`| l
_ ] j ] d
{ ` u p]q` w o dd
{ ~
{
pb
| r ]q lj n u l
` q` j s
\
{r b s \
` _ l
_ f t \
` l u
` ]_ ]q` ]q no| ` j s
` u] j ubq n] j l
` u l
j sb
] j lmj s
` q n] s
` u z \b d
` f
f h
` ikj lmj n d
` ]q j lmj n nb ] d
_ t \
` _ s
o u
` j s
_ zq l s
` ub zj s \
` l
q d
` ]q j lmj n nb ] d
_ w
bq _` d w
_ s
o u
{ lj n
f
f
` d w
_ s
o u
{ lj n t \
` _ s
o u
` j s
_ ] po l] j s s \
`| _` dk
` _ lj u
`r ` j u
` j sd
{ zl s \
s \
` sbr l p
f ^j s \l
_
r \^]_` ] d
_ b d
` p s
o q` _ p] j ~
` b
` q` u sb _ or r bq s
s \
` _` d w
_ s
o u
{ lmj n
f
f \^]q lmj n s \
` q` _ o d s
_ t \
` _ s
o u
` j s
_ pb| r ]q` s \
` l
q _ b d
o slb j_ ] j u s
q{ sb \
` d
r ` ] p \
b s \
` q sb o j u
` q _ s] j u s \
` sbr l p
f
` ]q j lj n nb ] d
_ ]q` p \
` p v
` u
] j u ikj ] d pb j pd
o _ l
b j_ ]q` u q ] zj f
1 Y P W T
[
q b ~d
`| t
b
r l p
]_` mbq _` ] d
r \^] ~
` s: ]_ l p pb j p`r s
_
]_` e [
q b ~d
`| _ b d lmj n pb| r ] j{ b u
` ddlj nr q b ~d
`| _yx
s \
` l
q ul po d s
{ ] j u
_ b dk ] ~ldl s
{
]_` }
` ]q p \ w bq
| ] ld] u u
q` _ _` _ ] j u
r q` pb| r ld
` q w
bq
r q b nq ]| | lj n d
] j no ] n`
` no d^]
q ` r q` _ _ l b j_
]_` cb
` ` ]o sb| ] sb j h
` s
` q| lmj l _ sl p i
j l s
` ]o sb| ] s]
]_` b j u
` s
` q| lmj l
_ sl p` ul s bq
mb j u
` s
` q| lmj l _ sl p i
j l s
` ]o sb| ] s] ] j u u
` s
` q| lj l
] slb j
]_`
b
| ] j p \
` p vlj n` ]| _ lj l s
` ]o sb| ] s] _ f
q` no d^]q ` r q` _ _ l
b j_yx ]o sb| ] s]
]_` a
q ] j u
| ]
_ q \
{| ` [
o
| r lj n
`| | ]
]_`
_{ _ s
`| _ l u
` ] b w nq ]| | ]q _
]_` []q ] j s \
` _` _r ]q _ lmj n [
o _ \ ub zj ]o sb| ] sb j
]_`
q l s \
| ` sl p p] d po d^] sbq ¡ e ¢ nq ]| | ]q _x
q` po q _ l
` r ]q _` q
]_` e a
` j` q ] d
r ]q _` q s \
` £¤ ] d
nbq l s \
| ] j u
\
b
| _ v
{ j bq| ] d w
bq
|
¥
s
q ] s s
q l ~ o s
` nq ]| | ]q ] j u
r ]q _` q sb b d
_
]_` e e
o
| | lmj n| ] p \lmj
` ~^]_ l p_ b w t
o q lmj n| ] p \lmj
` _
]_` e } l ~
q ]q{ w
o j p s l b j_ w
bq t
_ u
` `r ` qr q ] p sl p`
b j t
o q lmj n| ] p \lmj
` _
]_` e [
q b nq ]| | lmj n pb| r ` s l s l
b j ¦j l^
` q _ ] d
| ] p \l
j
` _
] j uco j l` q _ ] d d^] j no ] n` _x _ b dk ] ~ldl s
{ r q b b w
_
]_` e [ \ldb_ br \l p] d
pb j_
l u
` q ] s lb j_
\
o q p \ t o q lmj n
s \
` _` _yx dl
| l s
_ b w
pb
| r o s] slb j f
]_` e [
q b ~d
`| _ b d lmj n pb| r ] j{ ] n]
lmj §` q l
` z
q` l _ l s
` u b w s \
` r q lj pl
r d
` _ d
` ]q j st
] ~d
` em¨ [
q b ~ d
`| p]_` _ ] j u s \
` l
q d
` ]q j lj n nb ] d
_
(
¡t=¤O¤h ª©r¦»·8 . =Í ·c§ ¥B ¡)¢ ¤QC·h·8 t¬¬«
.I¡t¤ = ¢ »·c§¬ ¤ =¤ =¥) = ¦Å¡.¤Q)
?AäëíÕöõóå÷ üå_ðëð´àóêá qíéxõ ®åPð´úítñï
?AäëíÕöõóå÷ ' ¯ ¯ °
?AäëíÕöõóå÷
° ° °
?AäëíÕöõóå÷ µ °5±¯ ¯ °
?AäëíÕöõóå÷ À ¯ ¯ ¯
?AäëíÕöõóå÷ Ï
°5±¯ °5±!¯ °
?AäëíÕöõóå÷ Þ °5±¯ ¯ °
?AäëíÕöõóå÷ ° °5±!¯ °
?AäëíÕöõóå÷ ° ° ¯
?AäëíÕöõóå÷ ¯ ¯ °5±!¯
?AäëíÕöõóå÷ " ¯ ¯ °5±!¯
?AäëíÕöõóå÷
²' ¯ ¯ °5±!¯
?AäëíÕöõóå÷ Õ ¯ ¯ ¯
?AäëíÕöõóå÷
3µ ° °5±!¯ ¯
?AäëíÕöõóå÷
À ¯ ° °
?AäëíÕöõóå÷ Ï ° ° °
# éxöÇõâå µç@³ õ éxïëïæà
3
î6éòðæàâíÕêJí´%dð´úå[ìäëíÕöõâå_÷ïæåPðæðæàâêá4ôáxíéxõâïhéòêñ÷Cå_ðæúítñïOéxï8íxìYå_ê °
íÕähîõâíxïæåñ
¯ û