5-NN (squared error)
&^=n4FbaYÐkH=ÆIÐ rÍSYl_lB7@?GWVWbWF?_ZVW^;B7@]BAg>+GWCQ@PVWT?YZVW^;_À>A^=b)VaYZEÀ¿YZbt>AVWFbaYB7iVt>A^=@?YlX]F?GW^=@n
qÞÇ\ÔSÔ(_ZfM>7GaGW^ËÊNYZbce^=VWT¼G(#DFN>AbaYlX]YZbWbaB7b`E+YZVWbW^;_lG^=@u>,GaVt>A@?X?>AbaX@?B7bWE|>Af=^=ÛIYlX¼Ga_I>Af;Y4H
yT^;G`^;G`VWT?YÀGt>AE+YÀbaYl_lB7@?GaVWbWF?_ZVW^;B7@z>7G`^=@#VWT?YÀf;B9cpYZb bW^=n4TPV¿N>A@?YZfÌBAg&^=n4FbaY|ÐkH=ÆIq
iFVe^=@>Xk^ sYZbaYZ@DVSGa_I>Af;Y4H
) ßk¿YZbW^=E+YZ@DVo^=@?Xk^;_I>AVaY`VWTN>AVrÄoÇ\R%$ ~ >A@?XÁVWT?Y*}>ICwYlGW^M>A@E+YZVWT?BQXGrn4^=vwYGaFkg¹Ç
ÊN_Z^;YZ@PVrbaYlGWFf=VaGrghB7beVWT^;Gr¿N>AbWVW^;_ZFfM>AbSX?>AVt>kH
2¥j\§©¨ ! ! k¤ Ì¢ 4¬P£ w\¤ Ì¢
¼Yece^=f=fgÑBD_ZF?GUB7FbdXYZE+B7@?GWVWbt>AVW^;B7@,B7@|VWT?YrbaYl_lB7@?GWVWbWF?_ZVW^;B7@?GdBAg VWT?Yr}dFEÀE+YZbd>A@?X
}pFE10UE+BDXYZf;G>A@?X ]ÄoÇ\R%$
~
E+YZVWT?BQX HyT?Yd_aT^=baB7@?B7EÀ^;XQÇÈ^=@kgÑYZbWbaYlXÀE+YI>A@ !4Ff=C >A^=b
VaYZEÀ¿YZbt>AVWFbaYBAgVWT?Y}dFEÀE+YZboE+BQXYZfsgÑB7brVWT?Y 0SB7f;BQ_lYZ@?Y`bt>A@nwYlGoiYZVjcpYlYZ@]>AisB7FV
Ó " >A@?XÆ4Æ Ó" ce^=VWTz>ÁGWf=^=n4TPV BIvwYZbt>Af=fp_lBQB7f=^=@nOVWbaYZ@?X#gÂbaB7E VWT?Y|YI>AbWf=CT?B7f;BQ_lYZ@?Y
VaBÀVWT?Y`¿baYlGaYZ@DVIH2&^=n4FbaY ÐkH=Æ9à!^=f=f=F?GaVWbt>AVaYlGrVWT?YghFf=f #DFN>A@PVW^ËÊN_I>AVW^;B7@BAgF@?_lYZbWVt>A^=@DV\C
baYZfM>AVaYlXVaB%VWT?YÀ}pFEÀE+YZb`baYl_lB7@?GaVWbWF?_ZVW^;B7@L<LceT^;_aTz>Af=f;BIcrG`F?GVaBÁGWVWF?XkCVWT?YE+B4GWV
¿baB7iN>Aif;Y>AbaYI>7G2^=@ÏÂVW^=E+Y4<VaYZEÀ¿YZbt>AVWFbaY9Ö\ÇÈ¿fM>A@?Yun4^=vwYZ@æVWT?YB7i?GaYZbWvwYlXæX?>AVt> >A@?X
E+BDXYZf>7GtGWFEÀ¿VW^;B7@?GIHÌyT?Y GWTN>7XYlGrBAg &^=n4FbaY*ÐkH=Æ9à^=@?Xk^;_I>AVaY*¿B4GaVaYZbW^;B7br¿baB7iN>Ai^=fËÇ
^=V\C¼XYZ@?GW^=VW^;YlG ÀyT?Y2X?>AbWÎwYZbVWT?Y|GWTN>7XYlG9<VWT?Y|T^=n4T?YZb!VWT?Y|¿sB4GWVaYZbW^;B7b ¿baB7iN>Ai^=f=^=V\C
XYZ@?GW^=V\CwHyT?Y]E|>AbWn4^=@N>Af`¿sB4GWVaYZbW^;B7b,¿baB7iN>Ai^=f=^=VjC XYZ@?GW^=V\CGaFbÙgÑ>7_lYBAg*VWT?YYZ@PvQ^ËÇ
baB7@E+YZ@PVt>Af v4>AbW^M>Aif;YSbaYZ¿baYlGtYZ@PVaGeVWT?Y)v4>AbW^M>Ai^=f=^=V\C2>A@?X2¿baB7iN>Ai^=f=^=VjC2XYZ@?GW^=VjC|v4>Af=F?YlG
ghB7bp>A@DCn4^=vwYZ@|VW^=E+Yr¿sYZbW^;BQXÀE+B7baYe^=f=f=F?GWVWbt>AVW^=vwYZf=CÀVWTN>A@,VWT?YrVWbt>7Xk^=VW^;B7@N>AfN¿sB7^=@PVdYlGWVW^ËÇ
E|>AVaYlG{GWF?_tT!>7G{Y0ßk¿sYl_ZVt>AVW^;B7@!>A@?Xv4>AbW^M>A@?_lY4H &^=n4FbaYdÐkH=Æ9àe>Af;GaBSGWVt>AVaYlGLVWT?YU}e>ICwYlGW^M>A@
¿YZbaGW¿sYl_ZVW^=vwYoY0ßk¿f=^;_Z^=VWf=C VWT?YZbaYS^;GU@?B VWbWF?YrbaYl_lB7@?GaVWbWF?_ZVW^;B7@2^=@,VWT?Yr¿baYlGaYZ@?_lY)BAgLF@kÇ
_lYZbWVt>A^=@PV\CwHÌ[\@?GWVaYI>7X <wVWT?YZbaYo>AbaYeE+B7baYrB7bUf;YlGtG¿baB7iN>Aif;YrbaYl_lB7@?GWVWbWF?_ZVW^;B7@?Gpn4^=vwYZ@+VWT?Y
B7i?GaYZbWvwYlXX?>AVt>+>A@?X%E+BQXYZf>7GaGWFEÀ¿VW^;B7@?G9H
yT?YoF¿¿sYZbf;Y0gÂVd¿N>A@?YZf BAg&^=n4FbaY`ÐkH=ÆIÒ^=f=f=F?GWVWbt>AVaYlGVWT?Y)¿sB4GWVaYZbW^;B7bY0ßQ¿sYl_ZVt>AVW^;B7@
_ZFbWvwYdBAg?VWT?Ye>A^=bVaYZEÀ¿sYZbt>AVWFbaYdB7iVt>A^=@?YlXF?Ga^=@nSVWT?Y}dFEÀE+YZbrÏhGaB7f=^;X*f=^=@?Y9Ö>A@?X!VWT?Y
BIvwYZbaXk^;GW¿sYZbaGaYlXO}dFE E+BDXYZf{}dFE10,ÏhX?>7GWT?YlXÁf=^=@?Y9Ö0H&^=n4FbaY ÐkH=ÆIÒÀGaT?BIcrGSVWTN>AVoVWT?Y
BIvwYZbt>Af=fVWbaYZ@?XisYZV\cpYlYZ@|VWT?Ye}pFEÀE+YZbÌ>A@?XÀ}dFE 0 baYl_lB7@?GWVWbWF?_ZVW^;B7@?G^;GbaB7Fn4Tf=C!VWT?Y
Gt>AE+Y4HUyT?Y`f;B9cpYZb)¿N>A@?YZf{BAg&^=n4FbaY!ÐkH=ÆIÒn4^=vwYlGS>_Zf;B4GaYZboVW^=E+Y*GaYZbW^;YlGo>A@N>Af=CkGW^;GgÑB7b
0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 8000 9000 8
9 10 11 12 13
Time before present
Air temperature
&^=n4FbaYpÐkH=Æ9à [\@kgÑYZbWbaYlX!4Ff=C`E+YI>A@ VaYZEÀ¿YZbt>AVWFbaY>AV{yGWF?B7f=iE|>W>IvDbW^È<7¿baYlGtYZ@PVaYlX>7G
Gt>AEÀ¿f;Y0Ç\Ga¿Yl_Z^ËÊN_,¿B4GaVaYZbW^;B7b!Xk^;GWVWbW^=iFVW^;B7@?G!F?GW^=@n]VWT?Y2}>ICwYlGW^M>A@ }pFEÀE+YZb!E+BQXYZf
gÑB7b+YI>7_aTGtYlXk^=E+YZ@PV+fM>ICwYZb,GWVWF?Xk^;YlX H `>AbWÎwYZb+GWTN>7XYlGÀ^=@?Xk^;_I>AVaYT^=n4T?YZb+¿B4GaVaYZbW^;B7b
XYZ@?GW^=VW^;YlG9H
}dFE10Ì>A@?X!}dFEÀE+YZbbaYl_lB7@?GWVWbWF?_ZVW^;B7@?GIH[\V^=f=f=F?GWVWbt>AVaYlGU>e¿sB7^=@PVjce^;GaY
v4>Af=F?YÌghB7bVWT?Y
TDCD¿sB7VWT?YlGW^;GVWTN>AV{VWT?YUB7i?GaYZbWvwYlX f;BQ_I>AfP_lB7bWbaYZfM>AVW^;B7@!BQ_l_ZFbaGiPC`_aTN>A@?_lY4HyT?YÌGaE|>Af=f;YZb
v7>Af=F?YSVWT?YSE+B7baYSf=^=ÎwYZf=CÀ^=Vd^;GpVWTN>AVdVWT?Y)B7i?GaYZbWvwYlX2_lB7bWbaYZfM>AVW^;B7@ÁXBDYlGd@?B7VBD_l_ZFbpiPC
_tTN>A@?_lY4H -B7baYSGW¿sYl_Z^ËÊN_I>Af=f=Cw<DVWT?Y
v4>Af=F?Yr^;GdB7iVt>A^=@?YlX2iPCÀF?GW^=@n>*Gaf=^;Xk^=@n*ce^=@?XBIc
BAg AmGaYlXk^=E+YZ@PVfM>ICwYZbaGr>A@?X|^=Vp^=@?Xk^;_I>AVaYlGVWT?Yo¿baB7iN>Ai^=f=^=VjC2>AVdceT^;_aT%VWT?YSB7i?GtYZbWvwYlX
_lB7bWbaYZfM>AVW^;B7@BQ_l_ZFbaGiPC _aTN>A@?_lYÁGaF¿¿B4GW^=@n#baYl_lB7@?GaVWbWF?_ZVW^;B7@?GÀcpYZbaYÁ^=@?XYZ¿sYZ@?XYZ@PV
ce^=VWT^=@!VWT?YÌce^=@?XB9cäPyT?YpYZ@?X*¿sB7^=@PVaGBAg?VWT?YÌ_ZFbWvwY>AbaYpVWT?YÌEÀ^;Xk¿sB7^=@PVaGBAg?VWT?YÌÊ?baGWV
>A@?XVWT?YfM>7GWV`ce^=@?XB9cH
v4>Af=F?YlGcpYZbaY+YlGWVW^=E|>AVaYlX¼F?GW^=@n -B7@DVaY Ý >AbWf;B%E+YZVWT?BQX
iDC+_lB7EÀ¿N>AbW^=@n!VWT?YSB7i?GaYZbWvwYlX2_lB7bWbaYZfM>AVW^;B7@?GpVaB*VWT?Yo_lB7bWbaYZfM>AVW^;B7@?GeBAgUÆI444*¿N>A^=baGpBAg
bt>A@?XB7E ¿sYZbWE*FVt>AVW^;B7@?GrBAgLVWT?Y)ce^=@?XBIcrG9HyT?Y
v4>Af=F?YS_ZFbWvwY)^=@?Xk^;_I>AVaYlGVWTN>AVdVWT?Y
VW^=E+YeGaYZbW^;YlGU^=@ÀVWT?YF¿¿YZbf;Y0ghV¿N>A@?YZf?BAg$&^=n4FbaYoÐkH=ÆIÒ`>AbaYeGW^=EÀ^=fM>Ab^=@ÀVaYZbWE+GÌBAgf;BQ_I>Af
_lB7bWbaYZfM>AVW^;B7@¼_lBQY|_Z^;YZ@PVaGSgÑB7bSVWT?Y VW^=E+Y*^=@DVaYZbWv7>Af;Gå4q44>6PmPq44%>A@?Xq444>6QÐAmP42_I>Af
CQbr}RH
yT?YrF¿¿sYZbÌbW^=n4TDVp¿N>A@?YZfsBAg&^=n4FbaYÐkH=ÆIÒ`^=f=f=F?GaVWbt>AVaYlGpÄoÇ\R%$ ~ baYl_lB7@?GaVWbWF?_ZVW^;B7@
ÏhX?>7GWT?YlXf=^=@?Y9Ö{>A@?X*VWT?Yp}pFEÀE+YZbbaYl_lB7@?GWVWbWF?_ZVW^;B7@ÁÏhGaB7f=^;Xf=^=@?Y9Ö0HyT?YpE+B4GWVGWCkGWVaYZEÇ
>AVW^;_UXk^ sYZbaYZ@?_lYUiYZVjcpYlYZ@*ÄoÇ\R%$ ~ >A@?X`VWT?YÌ}pFEÀE+YZbbaYl_lB7@?GWVWbWF?_ZVW^;B7@?G^;G VWTN>AVLVWT?Y
VaYZEÀ¿YZbt>AVWFbaY ¿baYlXk^;_ZVW^;B7@?GBAgUVWT?YÄrÇ\R%$
~
E+BQXYZf>AbaY>AiB7FV!ÆIÓ
"
T^=n4T?YZb)VWTN>A@
VWT?Y`}pFEÀE+YZbeVaYZEÀ¿sYZbt>AVWFbaY`¿baYlXk^;_ZVW^;B7@?GIH &^=n4FbaYÐkH=ÆIÀGWT?BIcrGoGWVt>A@?X?>AbaX%@?B7bWE|>AfËÇ
^=ÛIYlXÀbaYl_lB7@?GWVWbWF?_ZVW^;B7@?GpghB7bÌVWT?Yr}dFEÀE+YZbd>A@?X+ÄoÇ\R%$ ~ E+BQXYZf;GIH[\VÌn4^=vwYlGp>vQ^;GWFN>Af
^=@?Xk^;_I>AVW^;B7@¼VWTN>AV`]ÄoÇ\R%$
~
>A@?Xu}pFEÀE+YZb`baYl_lB7@?GaVWbWF?_ZVW^;B7@?G >AbaYbaB7Fn4Tf=C#GW^=EÀ^=fM>Ab
^=@OGWVt>A@?X?>AbaX@?B7bWE|>Af=^=ÛIYlX]Ga_I>Af;Y4HÄÅ_Zf;B4GaYZb #DFN>A@PVW^=Vt>AVW^=vwY!VW^=E+Y0Ç\GaYZbW^;YlG>A@N>Af=CQGa^;GI<^=@
ceT^;_aT_lB7bWbaYZfM>AVW^;B7@]_lBQY|_Z^;YZ@PV)^;GS_I>Af;_ZFfM>AVaYlXOgÑB7boYI>7_aTGaYlXk^=E+YZ@PV)fM>lCwYZb`>A@?X^=VaG
v7>Af=F?Y^;GUYlGaVW^=E|>AVaYlXÀiPC -]B7@PVaY Ý >AbWf;BGa^=E*FfM>AVW^;B7@|^=@?Xk^;_I>AVaYlGÌVWTN>AVI<D>A¿N>AbWVghbaB7EVWT?Y
YI>AbWf=C 0)B7f;BQ_lYZ@?Y4<VWT?Y+V\cpBbaYl_lB7baXG nwYZ@?YZbt>Af=f=C¼iYZTN>IvwY|GW^=EÀ^=fM>AbWf=Cw<ce^=VWT >%¿N>AbWVW^;_0Ç
FfM>AbWf=C]nwBQBQX]Ê?VgÑB7b`VWT?Y+VW^=E+YÀ^=@DVaYZbWv7>Af;Gå4q44>6PmP44O>A@?XumPq44>6QÐ4å44_I>AfUCQb*}R
ÏÂVWT?Y`f;BIcdYZbobW^=n4TPVo¿N>A@?YZf{BAg&^=n4FbaY*ÐkH=ÆIÒwÖ0H
yT?YZbaYo>AbaYeB7@f=C!VWTbaYlYrGW^=VaYlG^=@ÀVWT?YeE+BQXYZbW@ÀVWbt>A^=@^=@n*X?>AVt>ceT?B4GaY $ )[{v4>Af=F?YlG
>AbaY*GWE|>Af=f;YZbSVWTN>A@OVWT?YE|>Þßk^=E*FE $ )[B7i?GaYZbWv4>AVW^;B7@^=@OVWT?Y*y{GaF?B7f=iE|>W>IvDbW^_lB7baY
ÏhGaYlY &^=n4FbaY#ÐkH.à4Ö0H yT^;G2^=@?Xk^;_I>AVaYlG2VWTN>AV%VWT?YyGWF?B7f=iE|>a>lvQbW^_lB7baY]TN>7G2_lB7f;XYZb
>A^=b)VaYZEÀ¿sYZbt>AVWFbaYÀv4>Af=F?YlGVWTN>A@VWT?YE+BDXYZbW@#VWbt>A^=@^=@nGaYZV`B7@¼>lvwYZbt>AnwY4<{¿baBIvQ^;XYlX
VWTN>AVVWT?Yo>7GaGWFEÀ¿VW^;B7@O:2$ )[{TN>7GÌ>`¿B4GW^=VW^=vwYe_lB7bWbaYZfM>AVW^;B7@,ce^=VWT|>A^=bUVaYZEÀ¿sYZbt>AVWFbaY4:w^;G
v7>Af=^;XYl_lB7f;B7n4^;_I>Af=f=CwHoyT^;G)^;GS>+¿B4GaGa^=if;Y¿sB4GW^=VW^=vwY*Y0ßk¿fM>A@N>AVW^;B7@]ghB7bSceTPC}dFEÀE+YZb
>A@?X,}dFE10eE+BQXYZf;GdbaYlGWFf=Vd^=@2_lB7f;XYZbr>A^=bdVaYZEÀ¿YZbt>AVWFbaY)baYl_lB7@?GWVWbWF?_ZVW^;B7@?GVWTN>A@%VWT?Y
B7i?GaYZbWvwYlXÁE+BQXYZbW@E+YI>A@>A^=beVaYZEÀ¿sYZbt>AVWFbaY4<?F@f=^=ÎwY`VWT?Y`ÄoÇ\R%$ ~ E+BQXYZfÈH
¹ ¨ ¥!?¤"! k¤{¥\¤{ k¨s¥` !N¬Ì¬ !7¨ wȤ ¤. !¨ Ȭ !§ !N¬w¨ 4£Ì¬ !
¬ ! k¤ Ì¢ 4¬P£ wȤ
[\@VWT^;GÌGtYl_ZVW^;B7@ÀcpYrXk^;Ga_ZF?GtGVWT?Yr>A^=bUVaYZEÀ¿sYZbt>AVWFbaYrbaYl_lB7@?GWVWbWF?_ZVW^;B7@2B7iVt>A^=@?YlXÀF?GW^=@n
VWT?Y`}pFEÀE+YZbSE+BDXYZfsghbaB7E >!¿N>Af;YlBQYl_lB7f;B7n4^;_I>Af{¿sB7^=@PVoBAgvQ^;YZcÕ)y 4 7\H
º{·l¯I³ 9+µOµD³´ +¹²Á¾ +¾ ½wµQº{µ]½w³ ¶ ½w³+p²L´
[\@kgÑYZbWbaYlX !wFf=Cz>A^=bVaYZEÀ¿YZbt>AVWFbaYlGÀXkFbW^=@n#VWT?Y2YI>AbWf=C 0)B7f;BQ_lYZ@?Y,cdYZbaYÁ>AiB7FVVWT?Y
Gt>AE+Y|>7G VaBDX?>ICw<iFV ce^=VWTxGaYZvwYZbt>Afpbt>A¿^;XuY0ß_ZFbaGW^;B7@?G iYZVjcpYlYZ@zcd>AbWE >A@?Xu_lB7f;X
¿YZbW^;BQXGIHyT?Y`baYl_lB7baXÁ^=@?Xk^;_I>AVaYlGoVWTbaYlY*GWF?_l_lYlGtGW^=vwY`_lB7f;X¼:ÕGW¿sYZf=f;GI:BAgU>A@>AEÀ¿f=^=VWF?XY
BAg 7 #47%$4Ó Ý >AV>AbaB7F@?X#4 44k< Ò4Ð44,>A@?X#Ò4 44,_I>AfCQb}dRHsyT?YlGaY!YZvwYZ@PVaG>AbaY
XkF?Y|VaBXk^;GWVW^=@?_ZV¿sYI>AÎQG ^=@ 03W1h306 Z1 &w546>A@?X GaB7E+Y2B7VWT?YZbÀ_lB7f;XQÇj>7X?>A¿VaYlX
_aT^=baB7@?B7EÀ^;XGGWFn4nwYlGWVW^=@n`>e¿baB7@?B7F@?_lYlX_aTN>A@nwYp^=@*VWT?YÌfM>AÎwY4:ÕGYZ@PvQ^=baB7@E+YZ@PVIHyT?Y
}pFEÀE+YZbÀbaYl_lB7@?GaVWbWF?_ZVW^;B7@^;G!^=@nwYZ@?YZbt>Afo>An4baYlYZE+YZ@PV+ce^=VWT^=@kgÑYZbaYZ@?_lYlGÀiN>7GaYlX B7@
Xk^M>AVaB7E+G>A@?X`¿sB7f=f;YZ@`ghbaB7E VWT?YUGt>AE+YU_lB7baY4äAVWT?YZC>Af=fw^=@kgÑYZbLbaYZfM>AVW^=vwYZf=Cf;BIcxiFVLbW^;GW^=@n
VaYZEÀ¿YZbt>AVWFbaYlGpXkFbW^=@nVWT?YrYI>AbWf=C 0SB7f;BQ_lYZ@?Y4<wceT^=f;YrXk^M>AVaB7E+Gd>7XXk^=VW^;B7@N>Af=f=CÀGWFn4nwYlGWV
>SXk^;GaVW^=@?_ZVUXkbaB7¿À^=@ÀVaYZEÀ¿YZbt>AVWFbaYlGÌ>AVÌ>AbaB7F@?X+Ò4 44_I>AfCQb}RÕ 0 ) 4< ~ }ekÆ0\H
Õ)y 4 A\H