• Ei tuloksia

Location Data, Personal Data Protection and Privacy in Mobile Device Usage : An EU Law Perspective

N/A
N/A
Info
Lataa
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Jaa "Location Data, Personal Data Protection and Privacy in Mobile Device Usage : An EU Law Perspective"

Copied!
172
0
0

Kokoteksti

(1)

#;=OFNSI@);Q 2HCP?LMCNSI@%?FMCHEC

%?FMCHEC#CHF;H>

0$"4*0/"4"&230/"-"4"204&$4*0/

"/%2*6"$9*/0#*-&&6*$&3"(&/

"7&231&$4*6&

0B;ECF;O-;MB;

!I=NIL;F>CMM?LN;NCIHNI<?JL?M?HN?>@ILJO<FC=?R;GCH;NCIH<S>O?J?LGCMMCIHI@NB?#;=OFNSI@

);Q;NNB?2HCP?LMCNSI@%?FMCHECCH0OIG?H);ECM;FC-&3 6FCIJCMNIHE;NOIH

!?=?G<?L;N;G

%?FMCHEC#CHF;H>

(2)

^0B;ECF;O-;MB;

&0+J;J?L<;=E

&0+-!#

2HCAL;@C;

%?FMCHEC

(3)

C

$,/07-&%(&.&/43

2H>?LN;ECHANBCM>I=NIL;FJLIAL;GB;M<??HIH?I@NB?GIMNMCAHC@C=;HN;H>FC@?=B;HACHA

?RJ?LC?H=?M@ILG?&NQIOF>HINB;P?<??H;==IGJFCMB?>QCNBIONNB?=IIJ?L;NCIHAOC>;H=?

;H>MOJJILNNB;N&L?=?CP?>@LIGG;HSJ?IJF?>OLCHAGSQILE

#CLMN;H>@IL?GIMN&QIOF>FCE?NI=IHP?SGSJLI@IOH>AL;NCNO>?NIGSMOJ?LPCMIL-LI@?MMIL -WCPC(ILJCM;;LC@ILB?L=IHNCHOIOMMOJJILNCHGS>I=NIL;FMNO>S;H>@C?F>MJ?=C@C=L?M?;L=B

%?LJ;NC?H=??H=IOL;A?G?HNGINCP;NCIH=IHMC>?L;NCIHCGG?>C;N?L?MJIHM?M;H>CGG?HM?

EHIQF?>A?I@NB?MO<D?=N;FQ;SM?;M?>GS?H>?;PIOLM&=;HHINCG;ACH?NB;NGS>CMM?LN;NCIH QIOF>B;P?<??HJIMMC<F?QCNBIONB?LMOJ?LPCMCIH;H>G?HNILCHA

& AL;N?@OFFS ;=EHIQF?>A? NB? @OH>CHA & L?=?CP?> NIQ;L>M GS >I=NIL;F JLIAL;G @LIG NB?

=;>?GSI@#CHF;H>@ILNB?&+02/"JLID?=N&;GAL;N?@OF@ILNB?@OH>CHA&L?=?CP?>NBLIOAB NB?*S$?I1LOMNJLID?=N@OH>?><S1?E?M`NB?#CHHCMB#OH>CHAA?H=S@IL&HHIP;NCIH;M Q?FF & ;FMI NB;HE@OFFS L?G?G<?L NB;N & L?=?CP?> ; AL;HN @LIG NB? "GCF ;FNIM?H 0WWNC[

@OH>?>JLID?=N%?HECF[NC?NID?HMOID;>CACN;FCMICNOP;MM;SBN?CMEOHH;MM;

&MCH=?L?FSNB;HEGSL?M?;L=BN?;GG?G<?LMH?NN?FYH0;PCEEI;H>'?HH;)CH>KPCMN@IL NB?CLCGJILN;HNMOAA?MNCIHM;MMCMN;H=?;H>=IGJ;HS<INBCHNB?M;G?JLID?=N;=NCPCNS;H>

CHGSJ?LMIH;FL?M?;L=BQILE

&QIOF>FCE?NI?RJL?MMGSNB;HEMNINB?JL??R;GCH?LMI@GS>CMM?LN;NCIH-LI@?MMIL*;LE IF? ;H> !I=?HN 1OIG;M -[SMNC @IL NB?CL CHMCABN@OF ;H> P;FO;<F? =IGG?HNM ;H>

?H=IOL;A?G?HN&NB;HE!I=?HN1I<C;MLWONCA;GQ;LGFS@ILN;ECHANB?L?MJIHMC<CFCNSNI;=N

;MGS,JJIH?HNCHNB?JO<FC=?R;GCH;NCIH

*SMCH=?L?NB;HEM;FMIAI?MNINB?!?J;LNG?HNI@+;PCA;NCIH;H>-IMCNCIHCHACH#CHHCMB

$?IMJ;NC;F /?M?;L=B &HMNCNON? #$& MJ?=C;FFS CNM !CL?=NIL -LI@?MMIL %?C>C (OOMHC?GC ;H>

0?HCIL/?M?;L=B0=C?HNCMN/I<?LN$OCHH?MMQBIJLIPC>?>G?QCNB;HIJJILNOHCNSNIDICH NB?CLN?;G;M)?A;F/?M?;L=BMMCMN;HNCH<?@IL?MN;LNCHAGS>I=NIL;FMNO>S;H>QBI MBIQ?> G? NB? Q;S NI >I L?M?;L=B QILE !OLCHA GS QILE CH #$& & G?N GS =OLL?HN MOJ?LPCMIL-LI@?MMIL(ILJCM;;LCQBC=BQ;M;AL?;NIJJILNOHCNS@ILG?

(4)

CC

MJ?=C;FNB;HEMNIGS@;=OFNS>?;H-LI@?MMIL-C;)?NNI3;H;GIQBICM;FMINB?@IOH>?L I@NB?=IGGOHC=;NCIHMF;Q>CM=CJFCH?CHNB?#;=OFNSI@);Q@ILB?LCHMCABN@OF=IGG?HNM;H>

AOC>;H=?>OLCHAGS>I=NIL;FQILE4CNBIONB?LCHP;FO;<F?MOJJILNCNQIOF>B;P?HIN<??H JIMMC<F?NI@CH>NB?LCABN>CL?=NCIHCHQBC=BNI=IHNCHO?GS>I=NIL;FL?M?;L=B

& BOG<FS ;JJL?=C;N? ;H> NB;HE NB? F;HAO;A? L?PCMCIH M?LPC=? I@ %?FMCHEC 2HCP?LMCNS ;H>

!I=NIL/I>?LC=E*= IH=BC?@ILNB?KOC=E;H>OM?@OFL?MJIHM?M;H>MOJJILN&L?=?CP?>1B?S B?FJ?>G?NICGJLIP?NB?F;HAO;A?KO;FCNSI@GS>CMM?LN;NCIH;FIN

&L?G?G<?LQCNBAL?;NAL;NCNO>?NI;FFNB?=IOLM?N?;=B?LM&=;G?;=LIMM;NNB?2HCP?LMCNSI@

%?FMCHEC P?LS MJ?=C;F NB;HEM NI -LI@?MMIL -;HO *CHEECH?H ;H> -LI@?MMIL 0OM;HH;

)CH>LIIM%IPCHB?CGI@ILNB?CLCHP;FO;<F?;>PC=?;H>@??><;=EIHGSL?M?;L=B

&;G;FMIP?LSAL;N?@OFNI*;LDOEE;);;EMI;H>*CEEI-OOEEI">O=;NCIH-F;HHCHA,@@C=?LM

"?P; %;LDO %/ 0J?=C;FCMN 0;HH; HNCJCH IHNLIFF?L ;H> HHC /CGGCH?H %/ I IL>CH;NIL;MQ?FF;MNIGS=IFF?;AO?M;H>@LC?H>MCHNB?@;=OFNS@ILNB?CLP;FO;<F?MOJJILN

;H>AOC>;H=?>OLCHAGS>I=NIL;FMNO>C?M

&QIOF>FCE?NI=IHP?SGSB?;LN@?FNNB;HEMNIGS@;NB?L*>HQ;LOF&MF;G@IL;FQ;SM

?H=IOL;ACHANLOMNCHA;H>MOJJILNCHAG?CH;NN;CHCHAGS>L?;GM#OLNB?LAL;NCNO>?CM>O?NI GS INB?L @;GCFS G?G<?LM L?F;NCP?M @LC?H>M ;H> ?P?LSIH? ?FM? QBI GINCP;N?> ;H>

;JJL?=C;N?>G?>OLCHAGSMNO>S;H>L?M?;L=B

#CH;FFS;H>GIMNCGJILN;HNFS&?RJL?MMGSQ;LG?MNAL;NCNO>?NIGSBOM<;H>*>*?M<;BOF

&MF;G@ILBCM=IHNCHO;F=;L?N?=BHC=;F;H>J?LMIH;FMOJJILN;H>CHMJCL;NCIHNBLIOABIONGS

>I=NIL;FL?M?;L=BQCNBIONQBIM?MOJJILNNB?DIOLH?SQIOF>HINB;P?<??H?;MSNNB?M;G?

NCG?&?RJL?MMGS>??JFIP?;H>;JJL?=C;NCIHNIGSMIH0BIGCE&MF;G@ILG;ECHACNJIMMC<F?

@ILG?NI=IGJF?N?NB?>CMM?LN;NCIHNB;N&MN;LN?><?@IL?B?=;G?CHGSFC@?

,=NI<?L

0B;ECF;O-;MB;

(5)

CCC

#342"$4

2MCHAFI=;NCIH<;M?>M?LPC=?M)0M PC;FI=;NCIH;Q;L?;JJFC=;NCIHM;JJM ;H>Q?<MCN?M IH>?PC=?MCH=FO>CHAMG;LNJBIH?MN;<F?NM;H>F;JNIJMB;M<?=IG?CH?PCN;<F?@ILGIMN>?PC=?

OM?LM0G;LNJBIH?M;H>MG;LN>?PC=?M;L??KOCJJ?>QCNBMIJBCMNC=;N?>JIMCNCIHCHAM?HMILM NB;N=;H>?N?LGCH?NB?FI=;NCIH;H>JBSMC=;FGIP?G?HNMI@NB?CLOM?LMP;LC?NSI@LCMEM;H>

NBL?;NMB;P?<??H;MMI=C;N?>QCNBNB?FI=;NCIH>;N;JLCP;=SI@CH>CPC>O;FMCHNBCM>CACN;F?L;

1BCM >CMM?LN;NCIH ;>>L?MM?M ; =IGGIH ;H> MCAHC@C=;HN F?A;F JLI<F?G NB? L?F;NCIHMBCJ

<?NQ??H=IFF?=NCIHI@FI=;NCIH>;N;CHGI<CF?>?PC=?OM;A?;H>NB?"OLIJ?;H2HCIH"2 F;QIHNB?JLIN?=NCIHI@J?LMIH;FFI=;NCIH>;N;;H>JLCP;=S

FIHA QCNB NB? NL;>CNCIH;F BOG;H LCABNM F;Q NB? "2 CH@ILG;NCIH ;H> =IGGOHC=;NCIHM N?=BHIFIAS& 1 ;MQ?FF;M>;N;JLIN?=NCIHF;QJF;S;MCAHC@C=;HNLIF?CHNB?JLCP;=S;H>

J?LMIH;F>;N;JLIN?=NCIHI@GI<CF?>?PC=?OM?LMLNC=F? I@NB?$?H?L;F!;N;-LIN?=NCIH /?AOF;NCIH$!-/ ?RJL?MMFSCH=FO>?MFI=;NCIH>;N;;M;HbC>?HNC@C?LcI@J?LMIH;F>;N;1BCM

>CMM?LN;NCIHJC=NOL?MNB?POFH?L;<CFCNC?MI@FI=;NCIH;H>FI=;NCIH>;N;QBC=BG;SJIN?HNC;FFS

<?M?HMCNCP?>;N; CHGI<CF?>?PC=?M;H>QBCF?OMCHANB?&HN?LH?N;H>J;LNC=OF;L;JJMIHNBIM?

>?PC=?M1B?NB?IL?NC=;F@L;G?QILE@ILNB?>CMM?LN;NCIHCH=FO>?MNB?"2;M;MCHAF?MI=C?NS CHNB?>CACN;F?HPCLIHG?HN;MQ?FF;MFI=;NCIHJLCP;=S;H>=LIMM<IL>?LCMMO?MOH>?L"2>;N;

JLIN?=NCIHF;Q1B?H??>NII<N;CHOM?L=IHM?HN;H>G;CHN;CHNL;HMJ;L?H=S;H>;==IOHN;<CFCNS IH<?B;F@I@IHFCH?JF;N@ILGM;H>INB?LL?MJIHMC<F?<I>C?M;M>;N;=IHNLIFF?LM;H>JLI=?MMILM

;L?;FMI>?M=LC<?>

1B?G;CH;MJ?=NL?F;N?>NIFI=;FCM;NCIHCHGI<CF?>?PC=?M=IH=?LHM>;N;JLIN?=NCIH;>>L?MMCHA JLIN?=NCIH I@ JLCP;=S IHFCH? ;H> J?LMIH;F >;N; QBC=B CH=FO>?M FI=;NCIH >;N; 1BCM ;MJ?=N

?GJB;MCM?M NB? ?@@C=C?H=S I@ "2 >;N; JLIN?=NCIH F?A;F MSMN?G GIL? MJ?=C@C=;FFS QCNB NB?

CHNLI>O=NCIHI@NB?$!-/QBC=B=;H?@@?=NCP?FS<CH>>;N;=IHNLIFF?LMMO=B;MGOFNCH;NCIH;F N?=BHIFIAS=IGJ;HC?MIHFCH?JF;N@ILGM;H>INB?L?HNCNC?M@ILM;@?AO;L>CHA>;N;MO<D?=NMe LCABNNIJLCP;=S;H>J?LMIH;F>;N;JLIN?=NCIH;H>@ILNB?JLIGINCIHI@MGIINB;H>M;@?JO<FC=

J;LNC=CJ;NCIHIHNB?&HN?LH?NPC;GI<CF?>?PC=?M

NNB?M;G?NCG?NB?>CMM?LN;NCIH=IP?LMCHN?LH;NCIH;F;H>"2);Q;MJ?=NMI@NB?GCNCA;NCIH I@ B;LG@OF L;>CI CHN?L@?L?H=? CH $FI<;F +;PCA;NCIH 0;N?FFCN? 0SMN?G $+00 ;H> L;>CI

=IGGOHC=;NCIHMSMN?G@ILNB?;==OL;=SCHFI=;NCIH?MNCG;NCIH;H>FI=;NCIHM?LPC=?M,HNB?

(6)

CP

ALIOH> I@ JLIN?=NCIH I@ JLCP;=S NB? "2 F;Q >I?M HIN J?LGCN OMCHA CFF?A;F >?PC=?M FCE?

D;GGCHA;H>MJII@CHA>?PC=?MQBC=BB;GJ?L$+00N?=BHIFIAS;H>M?LPC=?M

S L?M?;L=BCHA ; =IGJ;L;NCP?FS H?Q <L;H=B I@ F;Q ;H> ; H?Q NIJC= NB? >CMM?LN;NCIH

=IHNLC<ON?MNINB??@@C=C?HNJLIN?=NCIHI@FI=;NCIH>;N;;H>JLCP;=S

(7)

P

0/4&/43

=EHIQF?>A?G?HNMC

<MNL;=NCCC

IHN?HNMP

)CMNI@,LCACH;F-O<FC=;NCIHM

/?M?;L=B.O?MNCIHM

&HNLI>O=NCIH

-L?@;=?

&HN?L>CM=CJFCH;LSJJLI;=B;H>1?=BHIFIAC=;FMJ?=NM -LCP;=S;H>!;N;-LIN?=NCIH&H>C=;NCHA)I=;NCIH!;N;-LCP;=S

-LCP;=S;H>!;N;-LIN?=NCIHOH>?L/?F?P;HN);QM

0=IJ?I@-LCP;=S;H>!;N;-LIN?=NCIH

!?M=LCJNCIHI@/?M?;L=B.O?MNCIHM;H>LNC=F?M

*?NBI>IFIAS

;=EALIOH>!CM=OMMCIHIHNB?0I=CI)?A;FJJLI;=B

%IQNB?0I=CI)?A;FJJLI;=B4ILEM@IL"2!;N;-LIN?=NCIH);Q LIMM<IL>?L&MMO?MCH-?LMIH;F!;N;-LIN?=NCIH

"RNL; 1?LLCNILC;F0=IJ?

1L;HM@?LMI@-?LMIH;F!;N;

/?G;LEMIHNBCM/?M?;L=B.O?MNCIH

)I=;NCIH!;N;-LCP;=SCH0G;LNJBIH?M

IHM?HN0IG?/?F?P;HN!CM=OMMCIH

/?G;LEMIHNBCM/?M?;L=B.O?MNCIH

$+00;H>%;LG@OF/;>CI&HN?L@?L?H=?

&HN?LH;NCIH;F IIL>CH;NCIH

(8)

PC

0=?H;LCIMCHNB?"2

/?G;LEMIHFF/?M?;L=B.O?MNCIHM

3;LCIOMMJ?=NMI@)I=;NCIH!;N;

)I=;NCIH!;N;;H>0?HMCNCP?!;N;

0IOL=?MI@)I=;NCIH!;N;

);N?MN1?=BHIFIAC?M;H>)I=;NCIH!;N;

)I=;NCIH!;N;CHNB?&HN?LH?NI@1BCHAM"HPCLIHG?HN

$1?=BHIFIAS

B;FF?HA?MCH)I=;NCIH!;N;;H>)I=;NCIH<;M?>0?LPC=?MQCNB)?A;FLAOG?HNM %IQ;L?)I=;NCIH!;N;CH!;HA?LPC;)I=;NCIH<;M?>0?LPC=?M HIHSGCM;NCIH-M?O>IHSGCM;NCIH;H>-L;=NC=?MI@*;HS IGJ;HC?M &GJILN;HN-LIPCMCIHM;H>NB?/CABNMI@!;N;0O<D?=NMOH>?L$!-/@IL-LIN?=NCIH

I@-?LMIH;F)I=;NCIH!;N;

4B?HCMNB??-LCP;=S!CL?=NCP??-! IH=?LH?>

0IG?-IMCNCP?&HCNC;NCP?M<S&HN?LH?N-F;N@ILGM

IH=FOMCIH

/?G;LEM

0OGG;LCMCHANB?/?M?;L=B/?MOFNM

C<FCIAL;JBS

);QM;H> IGJF?G?HN;LS!I=OG?HNM

;M?0NO>S

JJ?H>CR,LCACH;F-O<FC=;NCIHM

(9)

*340'2*(*/"-5#-*$"4*0/3

1BCM>CMM?LN;NCIHCM<;M?>IHNB?@IFFIQCHAJO<FC=;NCIHM

& )",*-"5"3)"d"2;M;0CHAF?!CACN;F0I=C?NSQCNB/?F?P;H=?NINB?0I=CI )?A;FJJLI;=Be;==?JN?>@ILJO<FC=;NCIH 'IOLH;FI@!;N;-LIN?=NCIH -LCP;=S

&& )",*-"5"3)"d LIMM<IL>?LCMMO?MOH>?L"2>;N;JLIN?=NCIHF;QQCNBL?A;L>M NIJ?LMIH;F>;N;JLIN?=NCIHeJO<FCMB?> &H@ILG;NCIH IGGOHC=;NCIHM 1?=BHIFIAS);Q

&&& )",*-"5"3)"H?NN?F?H0;PCEEI'?HH;*WECH?H/I<?LN$OCHH?MM-WCPC (ILJCM;;LC d"2 );Q -?LMJ?=NCP?M IH )I=;NCIH !;N; -LCP;=S CH 0G;LNJBIH?M ;H>

&H@ILG?> IHM?HN @IL 1L;HMJ;L?H=Se JO<FCMB?> "OLIJ?;H !;N;

-LIN?=NCIH);Q/?PC?Q

&3 )",*-"5"3)" d3OFH?L;<CFCNC?M CH )I=;FCT;NCIH QCNB L?A;L> NI $+00 ;H>

%;LG@OF/;>CI&HN?L@?L?H=?&HN?LH;NCIH;F;H>"2);QMJ?=NMeJO<FCMB?>

&"""==?MM

(10)

&3&"2$)5&34*0/3

"3"3*/(-&%*(*4"-30$*&497*4)2&-&6"/$&404)&30$*0-&("-"1120"$),H?I@

NB?G;CHAI;FMI@NB?@ILG;NCIHI@NB?"OLIJ?;H2HCIH"2 Q;M?=IHIGC=JIFCNC=;F

;MQ?FF;MF?A;FCHN?AL;NCIH;H>B;LGIHCM;NCIH1B?$!-/CMNB?F;N?MN;>>CNCIHNINB?

B;LGIHCM;NCIHJLI=?MM=IP?LCHA;FF"2*?G<?L0N;N?MCHNB?@C?F>I@>;N;JLIN?=NCIH 1BCML?M?;L=BKO?MNCIH;MEMBIQNB?"2=IOF><??RJF;CH?>;M;MCHAF?MI=C?NSCH;

>CACN;F ?HPCLIHG?HN OH>?L ; MI=CIF?A;F IONFIIE CGJFSCHA CHN?L;=NCIH <?NQ??H MI=C?NSF;Q;H>N?=BHIFIAS

2033#02%&2 *335&3 5/%&2 %"4" 1204&$4*0/ -"7 7*4) 2&("2% 40 1&230/"-

*/$-5%*/( -0$"4*0/ %"4" 1204&$4*0/ LIMM<IL>?L >;N; @FIQ B;M <?=IG?

OH;PIC>;<F?QCNBNB?=IHMC>?L;<F?;H>?RJIH?HNC;F?RJ;HMCIHI@&HN?LH?N;=NCPCNC?M

;H>QILF>QC>?M?LPC=?M<SNB?GOFNCH;NCIH;FN?=BHIFIAS=IGJ;HC?M$CP?HMO=B;

AFI<;F ;H> CHN?LL?F;N?> N?=BHIFIAC=;F QILF> NBCM L?M?;L=B KO?MNCIH >CM=OMM?M NB?

JIMMC<CFCNSI@?RNL;N?LLCNILC;F;JJFC=;NCIHI@"2>;N;JLIN?=NCIHF;QCHNB?=;M?I@

=LIMM<IL>?LCMMO?M;H>=LIMM<IL>?L>;N;NL;HM@?LMQCNBL?@?L?H=?NIL?F?P;HN=;M?

F;QM

-"7 1&231&$4*6&3 0/ -0$"4*0/ %"4" 12*6"$9 */ 3."241)0/&3 "/% */'02.&%

$0/3&/4'0242"/31"2&/$9MOM?LM=;LLSMG;LNJBIH?MQCNBNB?GCH;FGIMN;FFCH NB?CL >;CFS FC@? MCNO;NCIHM ;H> MG;LNJBIH?M ;L? =IGJONCHA >?PC=?M =IGJ?N?HN NI J;LNC=CJ;N?CH;HSNSJ?I@&HN?LH?N;=NCPCNSJLCP;=S=IH=?LHM;L?GIL??RJIM?>;H>

KO?MNCIH;<F?CHMG;LNJBIH?MNB;H@ILINB?LGI<CF?>?PC=?M1BCML?M?;L=BKO?MNCIH

;LAO?M NB? H?=?MMCNS NI ;>IJN NL;HMJ;L?HN =F?;L ;H> MJ?=C@C= MN?JM ;H> F?A;F

;LL;HA?G?HNMNI?HMOL?OM?LJLCP;=SCHMG;LNJBIH?OM;A?;H>NB?CGJILN;H=?I@OM?L

=IHNLIFIP?LJ?LMIH;F>;N;NB;N=;H<??RJL?MM?><S?RJFC=CN=IHM?HN

5-/&2"#*-*4*&3*/-0$"-*3"4*0/7*4)2&("2%40-0#"-"6*("4*0/"4&--*4&934&.

"/% )"2.'5- 2"%*0 */4&2'&2&/$& /4&2/"4*0/"- "/% -"7 "31&$43

$+00M?LPC=?MCH=FO>CHA$FI<;F-IMCNCIHCHA0SMN?G$-0 ;L?IJ?L;N?>NBLIOAB

?RN?LH;FH?NQILEM;H>NB?L;>CIMJ?=NLOG0CH=?NB?OM?I@MIG?>?PC=?MMO=B;M D;GGCHA;H>MJII@CHA>?PC=?M=;HCHN?L@?L?QCNBNBIM?M?LPC=?MB;GJ?LCHA;==OL;N?

FI=;NCIH?MNCG;NCIHFI=;FCM;NCIHCHA?H?L;FCH=IHH?=NCIHNI$+00L;>CIMJ?=NLOG

;H>>;N;JLCP;=S;L?>?M=LC<?>OH>?LNBCML?M?;L=BKO?MNCIH

(11)

/420%5$4*0/

1B?&HN?LH?NB;M?RJ;H>?>NB?IJJILNOHCNSNIL?;=BGCFFCIHMI@J?IJF?MCGOFN;H?IOMFS;=LIMM NB?QILF>;FIHAQCNBNB?JIMMC<CFCNSI@E??JCHA;=NCPCNSL?=IL>M-?IJF?=;HA?NCH@ILG;NCIH

@LIG ;HS J;LN I@ NB? QILF> MCNNCHA CH NB?CL IQH LIIG IGJ;L?> NI NL;>CNCIH;F ;H;FIAO?

MOLP?CFF;H=?;H>CHN?L@?L?H=?G?;MOL?MQBC=B=IOF>CHP;>?CH>CPC>O;FJLCP;=SNB?&HN?LH?N CMGO=BGIL??@@?=NO;F@;LL?;=BCHA;H>=IGJ?N?HNNIGIHCNILIHFCH?;=NCPCNC?M;H>=L?;N?;

NBL?;NNIJLCP;=S?=;OM?NB?QILF>QC>?H;NOL?I@NB?;O>C?H=??RJIM?MJLCP;=SNI;AL?;N?L NBL?;NNB?>;N;JLIN?=NCIHF;QM;L?=OLL?HNFSGIL?L?F?P;HN;H>H??>GIL?L?M?;L=B

2&'"$&

&HNB?;L?;I@CH@ILG;NCIHN?=BHIFIASFI=;NCIH<;M?>N?=BHIFIASCMIH?I@NB?GIMNL;JC>FS ALIQCHA -IMCNCIHCHA M?HMILM ;L? CHM?LN?> CH ;FF MILNM I@ MG;LNJBIH?M ;H> MG;LN >?PC=?M HIQ;>;SM1BCMN?=BHIFIASCMP?LSJIJOF;L<?=;OM?I@CNMBCAB;==OL;=S;H>FIQ=IMN&NB;M G;>?CNMOM?LMe>;CFSFCP?M?;MC?L-?IJF??HA;A?CH;AL?;NP;LC?NSI@FI=;NCIH<;M?>M?LPC=?M )0M QCNBJIMCNCIHCHA=;J;<F?MG;LN>?PC=?M*;JJCHA;H>H;PCA;NCIHM?LPC=?M$FI<;F +;PCA;NCIH 0;N?FFCN? 0SMN?G $+00 QBC=B CH=FO>?M $FI<;F -IMCNCIHCHA 0SMN?G $-0

=B?=ECH;H>FI=;NCIHIJNCIHMIHMI=C;FG?>C;;H>M?=OLCNSM?LPC=?M@ILMNIF?HILGCMMCHA GI<CF?JBIH?M;L?P?LSOM?@OF@ILNB?OM?LMSOMCHAH;PCA;NCIH;JJFC=;NCIHM;JJM OM?LM

=;H@CH>NB?CL>?MNCH;NCIH?;MCFSIL;=;L=;H>?N?LGCH?QB?L?CNCMFI=;N?>)I=;NCIH<;M?>

M?LPC=?M;L?CHN?AL;N?>CHNIMI=C;FG?>C;JF;N@ILGM;H><INBI@NB?M?CHMJCL?NB?OM?LMNI MB;L?NB?CLFI=;NCIH>;N;)I=;NCIH>;N;G;E?MCN?;MSNI>?N?LGCH?QB?NB?L;J?LMIHCM;N BIG?ILIONMC>?;H>CHG;HS=;M?MNB?CL?R;=NFI=;NCIH#OLNB?LGIL?MG;LNFI=;NCIH<;M?>

N?=BHIFIASB;MCGJLIP?>KO;FCNSI@FC@?NBLIOABMO=BNBCHAM;M=IHH?=N?>B?;FNB=;L?;H>

=CNS;H>BIG?G;CHN?H;H=?MSMN?GM

NNB?M;G?NCG?NB?L?CM>?<;N?IP?LFI=;NCIHJLCP;=S;H>NB??;M?I@;==?MMCHAOM?LFI=;NCIH

>;N; IH NBIM? M?LPC=?M ;H> >?PC=?M 4B?H OMCHA MG;LN JIMCNCIHCHA >?PC=?M OM?LM

>CMM?GCH;N?J?LMIH;FFI=;NCIH>;N;NIINB?L=IHH?=N?>G;=BCH?MNBOML;CMCHAM?LCIOMJLCP;=S

'OHDC+;A;N;;H>INB?LMd"G?LACHAFI=;NCIH<;M?>M?LPC=?M;H>CNMJLCP;=S=IHNLIFeL>"OLIJ?;H /?ACIH;F IH@?L?H=?I@NB?&HN?LH;NCIH;F1?F?=IGGOHC=;NCIH0I=C?NS3C?HH;OMNLC;'OFS

*;LE4;NNM';G?MLOHA?L;H>(;N?0BCL?Md!I"OLIJ?;H>;N;JLIN?=NCIHF;QM;JJFSNINB?=IFF?=NCIHI@

4C#CH?NQILE>;N;@ILOM?CHA?IFI=;NCIHFIIEOJM?LPC=?Me &HN?LH;NCIH;F!;N;-LCP;=S);Q

F;O>? ;MN?FFO==C;;H>LPCH>+;L;S;H;Hd-LCP;=S=IHMC>?L;NCIHMI@IHFCH?<?B;PCIOL;FNL;=ECHAe

"OLIJ?;H+?NQILE;H>&H@ILG;NCIH0?=OLCNSA?H=S"+&0 BNNJMAIIAF40"J;==?MM?>

#?<LO;LS

4;NNMH

(12)

=IH=?LHM&HONCFCMCHAKOC=E?@@C=C?HN;H>CHMN;HN;>P;HN;A?MOM?LMCHG;HS=;M?MH?CNB?L

<INB?L;<IONNB?CLJLCP;=SHIL=;H@IL?M??;H>L?;FCM?NB?;=NO;FCGJ;=N&HIL>?LNI<?H?@CN

@OFFS@LIGNB?)0MOM?LMH??>NI;FFIQNBIM?M?LPC=?MILL?GIN?>?PC=?MNI;==?MMNB?CL

?R;=NFI=;NCIHCH@ILG;NCIHONC@M?LPC=?JLIPC>?LM;H>IHFCH?JF;N@ILGM;==OGOF;N?MO=B CH@ILG;NCIH NBCM =;H =IHMNCNON? ; NBL?;N I@ OH;HNC=CJ;N?> =IHM?KO?H=?M -LCP;=S LCME

?MJ?=C;FFS>CM=FIMOL?I@M?HMCNCP?CH@ILG;NCIHCM>??JFSCHPIFP?>CHNBCML?A;L>

ALIOJI@L?M?;L=B?LM<;M?>IHGIHNBMeMNO>SIHNB?BOG;HGI<CFCNS>;N;I@;LIOH>

GCFFCIHJ?IJF?B;MMBIQHNB;NI@J?IJF?=;H<?C>?HNC@C?>OHCKO?FSOMCHADOMN@IOL FI=;NCIH;H>NCG?L?F;N?>>;N;M?NJICHNM=;JNOL?><S;HN?HH;M1BCMMNO>S@IOH>NB;NJ?IJF?eM JLCP;=SCMOH>?LBOA?=IHMNL;CHNMQCNBL?A;L>NIFI=;NCIH>;N;

)I=;NCIHJLCP;=SCMIH?I@NB?<CAA?MN=IH=?LHMCHL?F;NCIHNINB?OM?I@GI<CF?>?PC=?M@N?L NB?b)I=;NCIHA;N?cL?P?F;NCIH<SNQIG?>C;L?M?;L=B?LM,/?CFFSF;M>;CLFF;H;H>-?N?

4;L>?HIHJLCF ;Nb4B?L?=IH@?L?H=?cNB;NC-BIH?;H>$C-;>L?=IL>NB?

>?PC=?Me JIMCNCIH OMCHA ; BC>>?H @CF? NB? =IH=?LH @IL FI=;NCIH >;N; JLIN?=NCIH IH GI<CF?

>?PC=?M;NNL;=N?>QILF>QC>?;NN?HNCIH IHM?KO?HNFSCHP?MNCA;NCIHI@INB?LGI<CF?JBIH?M

;H> ;JJFC=;NCIHM JLI>O=?> NB? ;F;LGCHA L?MOFN NB;N ; BOA? ;GIOHN I@ FI=;NCIH >;N; ;L?

=IFF?=N?>;H>MNIL?>NBLIOABNBIM?>?PC=?M;H>;JJMCH=?LN;CH=CL=OGMN;H=?M

2M?LM F?;P? b>CACN;F @IINJLCHNMc NBLIOAB NB?CL >CACN;F ;=NCPCNC?M &N CM IH? I@ NB? GIMN

>CM=OMM?>CMMO?MI@L?=?HNNCG?M;MM?LNCHANB;NNB?G?NBI>I@JLI=?MMCHAFI=;NCIH>;N;HIN IHFSCHPIFP?MN?=BHC=;FMSMN?GM<ON;FMIJIM?M;H?R=?MMCP?NBL?;NNINB?>CAHCNS;H>JLCP;=S I@ CH>CPC>O;FM 1B? =IH=?LH CH=FO>?M NB? M=IJ? I@ ;JJFC=;NCIH I@ L?F;N?> "2 F?A;F

+;A;N;H

6P?MF?R;H>L?>?*IHNDIS?;H>INB?LMd2HCKO?CHNB? LIQ>1B?JLCP;=S<IOH>MI@BOG;HGI<CFCNSe

%-3/8>303-$/:9<>=*;L=B

1B?C-BIH?CM;MG;LNJBIH?JLI>O=?><SNB?20<;M?>GOFNCH;NCIH;FN?=BHIFIAS=IGJ;HSJJF?QBC=B LOHMJJF?eMMJ?=C;FIJ?L;NCHAMSMN?GC,0Q?<IJ?>C;dC-BIH?e

BNNJMQQQQ?<IJ?>C;=IG1"/*&C-BIH?BNGF;==?MM?>#?<LO;LS

1B?C-;>CM;N;<F?N=IGJON?LQCNB;HC,0GI<CF?IJ?L;NCHAMSMN?GQBC=BCM>?MCAH?>F;OH=B?>;H>

G;LE?N?><SJJF?&H=Q?<IJ?>C;dC-;>eBNNJMQQQQ?<IJ?>C;=IG1"/*&C-;>BNGF;==?MM?>

#?<LO;LS

F;M>;CLFF;H;H>-?N?4;L>?Hd$IN;HC-BIH?IL$C-;>JJF?CML?=IL>CHASIOLGIP?Me$+.+<

,/?CFFSJLCF BNNJL;>;LIL?CFFS=IG;JJF?FI=;NCIHNL;=ECHABNGF;==?MM?>

#?<LO;LS

;CNFCH! INNLCFFd)I=;NCIH-LCP;=S4BI-LIN?=NMe 2/&0

/;H>S*;=d6IOL-BIH?*;S?1L;=ECHA6IOL"P?LS*IP?%?L?M%IQNI0NIJ&Ne*;S BNNJQQQH<=FIM;HA?F?M=IGH?QMFI=;F0G;LNJBIH?)I=;NCIH1L;=ECHA

BNGFCRTTBK"CNE;==?MM?>#?<LO;LS

!;PC>"L>IMd1B?N?HMCIH<?NQ??H>;N;JLIN?=NCIH@L??>IGI@?RJL?MMCIHe<//%://-2/,+>/*;S BNNJ@L??MJ??=B>?<;N?=IG?H>CM=OMM=IH@OM?>NB?N?HMCIH<?NQ??H>;N;JLIN?=NCIH@L??>IGI@

?RJL?MMCIH;==?MM?>#?<LO;LS

(13)

CHMNLOG?HNMIHNB?<IL>?LF?MMIHFCH?MJ;=?;H>CNM=IGJ?N?H=?NIN;=EF?NB?NBL?;NM<SNB?

AC;HNGOFNCH;NCIH;FN?=BHIFIAS=IGJ;HC?MI@CHP;>CHAJ?IJF?eMLCABNNIJLCP;=S;H>J?LMIH;F

>;N;JLIN?=NCIHQCNBL;H>IG>;N;JLI=?MMCHA

*O=BI@NB?L?M?;L=BQILECHNBCM>CMM?LN;NCIH;JJFC?M?KO;FFSQ?FFNIINB?LJILN;<F?>?PC=?M MO=B;MF;JNIJMN;<F?NM<ONNI;PIC>=IGJF?RCNSCNCM@I=OM?>IHMG;LNJBIH?M;NMIG?JICHNM HINB?LL?;MIHCMNB;N=IGJ;L?>NIINB?L>?PC=?MJ?IJF?E??JMG;LNJBIH?MQCNBNB?GGIMN I@NB?NCG?1BOMMG;LNJBIH?ML?JL?M?HNIH?I@NB?=IHMN;HN=IGJ;HCIHMCHNB?GIP?G?HNM I@G;HSJ?IJF?CHNB?CL?P?LS>;S>CACN;FFCP?M

0CH=? NB? =IFF?=NCIH OM? L?N?HNCIH ;H> NL;HMGCMMCIH I@ FI=;NCIH >;N; =IHN;CHM NB? LCME I@

JLCP;=S CH@LCHA?G?HN M?=OLCHA MO=B >;N; H?=?MMCN;N?M ; L?AOF;NILS @L;G?QILE 1BCM

>CMM?LN;NCIH?GJB;MCM?MNB?H??>@ILNL;HMJ;L?H=S;H>L?MJIHMC<CFCNS@LIGNB?;ONBILCNC?M;H>

?HNCNC?M=IH=?LH?>;M>;N;=IHNLIFF?LM;H>JLI=?MMILMOH>?LNB?"2>;N;JLIN?=NCIHF;QIL

$!-/ ;H> >?M=LC<?M BIQ NB? N?LGM =IH>CNCIHM ;H> JLCP;=S JIFC=C?M I@ GOFNCH;NCIH;F N?=BHIFIAS=IGJ;HC?MCHNB?OM;A?I@GI<CF?>?PC=?MMBIOF><?;LL;HA?>@IFFIQCHAF?A;F I<FCA;NCIHMCH=IHH?=NCIHNINB?=IFF?=NCIH;H>JLI=?MMCHAI@J?LMIH;FCH=FFI=;NCIH >;N;&N

?H>?;PIOLM NI JLIN?=N J?LMIH;F CH=F FI=;NCIH >;N; ;H> JLCP;=S ;A;CHMN OHF;Q@OF >;N;

=IFF?=NCIH ;H> JLI=?MMCHA L?F;NCHA NI NB? OM? I@ FI=;NCIH;Q;L? GI<CF? >?PC=?M MO=B ;M MG;LNJBIH?M;H>NBOM>?M=LC<?MNB?FCGCNMI@N?=BHIFIAC=;FONCFCM;NCIH

-LCP;=SB;MM?P?L;F>CG?HMCIHMCNCMHIN@?;MC<F?NI?H=IGJ;MM;FFNB?M?>CG?HMCIHMCHIH?

>CMM?LN;NCIH1B?>CMM?LN;NCIH=IP?LMJLCP;=SCMMO?MCH=IHDOH=NCIHQCNBN?=BHC=;F@?;MC<CFCNS

;H>FI=;NCIH>;N;=IFF?=NCIH;H>JLIN?=NCIHOH>?L"2>;N;JLIN?=NCIHF;Q@ILFI=;NCIH?H;<F?>

GI<CF?>?PC=?OM;A?&N;>>L?MM?MFI=;NCIH>;N;JLCP;=SCMMO?MI@&HN?LH?NOM?LMIHGI<CF?

>?PC=?M OH>?L L?F?P;HN "2 L?AOF;NCIHM ;H> >CL?=NCP?M ;A;CHMN ; <LI;> N?=BHIFIAC=;F

<;=EALIOH>SCH=ILJIL;NCHACGJILN;HNKO?MNCIHMI@CHN?LM?=NCHAN?=BHIFIAC?MFI=;NCIH;H>

JLCP;=S=IGJIH?HNMCNCMBIJ?>NB;N@ONOL??GJCLC=;FL?M?;L=BQCFF<?H?@CN;H><?JLIGIN?>

CHNB?;JJLIJLC;N?@C?F>$?H?L;F>CM=OMMCIHIHJLCP;=SCHM?=NCIH

%IQ?P?LMCH=?NB?LCABNNIJLCP;=SCMHIN;H?R=FOMCP?;H>;<MIFON?LCABNMIG??R=?JNCIHM B;P? ;FQ;SM <??H J?LGCNN?> ;H> =IFF?=NCIH ;H> JLI=?MMCHA I@ FI=;NCIH >;N; =;H <? >IH?

F;Q@OFFS NI MIG? >?AL?? M ;H ?R;GJF? NB? ;=NCPCNC?M I@ &HN?LH?N OM?LM ;L? L?MNLC=N?>

"OLIJ?;H2HCIHA?H=S@IL#OH>;G?HN;F/CABNM;H>NB? IOH=CFI@"OLIJ?+8.,99598?<9:/+8.+>+

:<9>/->3986+A%;H><IIE

(14)

MIG?QB;N CH =?LN;CH =CL=OGMN;H=?M ;H> "2 >;N; JLIN?=NCIH F;Q ;FFIQM MIG? F;Q@OF MOLP?CFF;H=?;H>GIHCNILCHAG?;MOL?M#OLNB?L>CM=OMM?>CHM?=NCIH

,H IH? L?M?;L=B KO?MNCIH NB? F;QM L?F;N?> NI N?F?=IGGOHC=;NCIH ;H> $+00 M?LPC=?M

>?MCAH?>NIGCNCA;N?B;LG@OFL;>CICHN?L@?L?H=?;L?>CM=OMM?>JJ;L?HNFSNBCM;MJ?=NG;S M??G>C@@?L?HN@LIG>;N;JLIN?=NCIH;H>JLCP;=SMJB?L?M<ONNB?L?CM;=IHH?=NCIHFIHA QCNBCHPIFPCHANB?JLCP;=SKO?MNCIHNBCM;MJ?=NCMJ;LNC=OF;LFSL?F;N?>NIPOFH?L;<CFCNC?MCH FI=;FCM;NCIH QCNB L?A;L>M NI $+00 M?LPC=?M ;H> NB? L;>CI =IGGOHC=;NCIHM MSMN?G QCNB JIMMC<F?LCMEM@LIGL;>CICHN?L@?L?H=?;H>OMCHAB;LG@OF>?PC=?M

-?LMIH;FFI=;NCIH>;N;JLIN?=NCIH;H>GCNCA;NCIHI@L;>CICHN?L@?L?H=?@IL;M?=OL?>FI=;NCIH

;H>H;PCA;NCIHMSMN?G>?G;H>>C@@?L?HNF?A;FNL?;NG?HNM;H>CHMNLOG?HNM;H>NB?=IGGIH N?LGNB?SMB;L?CMbFI=;NCIHc1B?@CLMNIH?CMNB?JLCG?=IHMC>?L;NCIHCHCH>C=;NCHAFI=;NCIH JLCP;=S;H>>;N;JLIN?=NCIHCHGI<CF?>?PC=?MNB?M;G?;FMIB;JJ?HMCHNBCM>CMM?LN;NCIH 1B?M?=IH>CMGIL?L?F;N?>NIL?>O=CHAJLI<;<F?CHN?L@?L?H=?CH;H;PCA;NCIHMSMN?GE??JCHA FI=;FCM;NCIHCH;A?H?L;FJIMCNCIH&HL?;FCNS=IGJ;L?>NINB??RJ?LCG?HNMIHFI=;NCIH>;N;

JLCP;=S;H>JLIN?=NCIHOH>?L"2>;N;JLIN?=NCIHF;QMF?A;FCHCNC;NCP?MCHN?H>?>NIJL?P?HN

$+00CHN?L@?L?H=?;L?HINQ?FF>?P?FIJ?>MI@;L

#ILNB?JOLJIM?I@NB?NIJC=CNCMCGJILN;HNNIG;E?MIG?N?LGCHIFIAS=F?;L

1B?N?LGbFI=;NCIHcCMNB?A?IAL;JBC=;FJIMCNCIHI@;J?LMIHILI<D?=N;N;J;LNC=OF;LJICHNCH NCG? &H INB?L QIL>M FI=;NCIH CM ?CNB?L ;<MIFON? MO=B ;M ; MJ?=C@C= JF;=? IL JIMCNCIH CH>C=;NCHAF;NCNO>?;H>FIHACNO>?IHNB?G;JILL?F;NCP?FCE?NB?;>>L?MMI@;H?;L<SJF;=?

ILJ?IJF?eMGIP?G?HNM&HNBCM>CMM?LN;NCIHFI=;NCIHCMCHN?H>?>NICH>C=;N?JF;=?L?ACIH

;H>GIP?G?HNMQCNBL?A;L>MNIJ?LMIHMI<D?=NMJLI>O=NMILCH@ILG;NCIH&H;>>CNCIHNB?

N?LG bFI=;FCM;NCIHc CH>C=;N?M NB? N?=BHCKO? I@ >?N?LGCHCHA NB? FI=;NCIH I@ GI<CF? >?PC=?

OM?LM

)I=;NCIH#ILOG9-+>398+>+"<3@+-C?3./638/===/==7/8>=+8.$/-977/8.+>398=3?LMCIH*;S

#CP?1B?G?MI@$?IAL;JBSd)I=;NCIHeBNNJA?IAL;JBSGL>IHHILANB?G?M>?@CHCNCIHMBNGF;==?MM?>

#?<LO;LS

N?=BIJ?>C;d)I=;FCT;NCIHeBNNJMQQQN?=BIJ?>C;=IG>?@CHCNCIHFI=;FCT;NCIHGI<CF?

=IGGOHC=;NCIH;==?MM?>+IP?G<?L

(15)

)I=;NCIH >;N; =;H <? J?LMIH;F ILA;HCM;NCIH;F IL A?H?L;F 1BCMCH=FO>?M ;HS >;N; ;NN;CH?>

@LIG NB? $+00 IL b$-0 $&0 =?FFNIQ?L IL INB?L L;>CI MCAH;F<;M?> NLC;HAOF;NCIH

;MMCMN?>$-0JIMCNCIHCHA>?PC=?MMSMN?GM;H>JLI=?MM?MA?IN;AA?>CG;A?MPC>?I;O>CI

;H>N?RN>I=OG?HNMM;N?FFCN?;H>;?LC;FCG;A?LS=IGJON?LCT?>>CACNCT?>;H>J;J?LG;JM&-

;>>L?MM FI=;NCIH JO<FC= >I=OG?HNM JO<FC= IL JLCP;N? >;N;<;M? PC>?I ;O>CI N?RN ;H>

CG;A?@CF?MFI=;NCIH<;M?>;JJFC=;NCIHMc%IQ?P?LJ?LMIH;FFI=;NCIH>;N;=IHMCMNMI@;HS CH@ILG;NCIH;<ION;H;NOL;FJ?LMIHeM=OLL?HNILJ;MNA?IAL;JBC=;FILA?IMJ;NC;FFI=;NCIHMIL GIP?G?HNM

==IL>CHANI/?=CN;FI@NB?$!-/bJLI@CFCHAc;H;NOL;FJ?LMIH;H>;ONIG;N?>JLI=?MMCHA I@J?LMIH;F>;N;=;H<?>IH?<S;H;FSMCHAMIG?J?LMIH;F;MJ?=NMCH=FO>CHA>;N;MO<D?=NeM FI=;NCIH;H>GIP?G?HN0O=BJLI@CFCHA;MQ?FF;MJLI=?MMCHAI@J?LMIH;F>;N;=;H<?>IH?

QB?HNB?F;QI@NB?"2IL*?G<?L0N;N?M;FFIQMIL>?G;H>MCNILQCNBNB??RJFC=CN=IHM?HN I@NB?>;N;MO<D?=N

==IL>CHANILNC=F? I@NB?$?H?L;F!;N;-LIN?=NCIH/?AOF;NCIH$!-/ FI=;NCIH>;N;

=;H<?=;J;<F?I@>CL?=NFSILCH>CL?=NFSC>?HNC@SCHA;>;N;MO<D?=N;H>NBOM=;H;=N;M;H C>?HNC@C?LILC>?HNC@SCHA?F?G?HNI@J?LMIH;F>;N;1BCMJLIPCMCIHCMP?LSCGJILN;HN<?=;OM?

CN Q;M JL?PCIOMFS L;NB?L OH=F?;L QB?NB?L ;H> QB?H FI=;NCIH >;N; =;H <? =IHMC>?L?> ;M J?LMIH;F>;N;1BCMJLIPCMCIHHIQMNCJOF;N?MNB;NFI=;NCIH>;N;;L?J?LMIH;F>;N;C@NB?S=;H C>?HNC@S;H;NOL;FJ?LMIH4B?L?FI=;NCIH>;N;;L?=IH=?LH?>NB?C>?HNC@C;<CFCNSI@NB?OM?LCM

$&0IL$?IAL;JBC=&H@ILG;NCIH0SMN?GCM;MSMN?GQBC=B=;JNOL?MMNIL?MOM?M;H;FSM?M;H>G;CHN;CHM;FF MILNMI@A?IAL;JBC=;F>;N;2HCP?LMCNSI@4CM=IHMCH*;>CMIH)C<L;LC?M/?M?;L=B$OC>?Md*;JJCHA;H>

$?IAL;JBC=&H@ILG;NCIH0SMN?GM$&0 4B;NCM$&0eBNNJML?M?;L=BAOC>?MFC<L;LSQCM=?>O$&0

;==?MM?>#?<LO;LS

=?FFNIQ?LCH;L;CM?>MNLO=NOL?NB;N@;=CFCN;N?M=?FFOF;L=IGGOHC=;NCIH<S@L;GCHA?F?=NLIHC=

=IGGOHC=;NCIH?KOCJG?HNCH=IIJ?L;NCIHQCNB;HN?HH;L?=?CP?LM;H>NL;HMGCNN?LMCH;H?NQILEN?=BIJ?>C;

d ?FF1IQ?LeBNNJMQQQN?=BIJ?>C;=IG>?@CHCNCIH=?FFNIQ?L;==?MM?>#?<LO;LS

H&HN?LH?N-LINI=IF;>>L?MMIL&-;>>L?MMJLIPC>?MC>?HNCNS;H>FI=;NCIHI@&HN?LH?N=IHH?=N?>GI<CF?

>?PC=?MNB;NCM>C@@?L?HN@LIGINB?L>?PC=?M4B;N&M*S&->>L?MMd4CNBION&->>L?MM?MNB?&HN?LH?N 4IOF>!CM;JJ?;LeBNNJQB;NCMGSCJ;>>L?MM=IGCJ;>>L?MM;==?MM?>0?JN?G<?L

)I=;NCIH#ILOGH

*=!IQ?FF-OL=?FFd!;N;-LIN?=NCIH,@@C=?CMMO?M$OC>;H=?IH)I=;NCIH!;N;e"OLIJ?;H2HCIH&L?F;H>

OAOMN BNNJMQQQF?RIFIAS=IGFC<L;LS>?N;CF;MJRA<<<<?;??<

?<@;==?MM?>#?<LO;LS

b-LI@CFCHAcCM>?@CH?>CHLNC=F? $!-/bdJLI@CFCHAeG?;HM;HS@ILGI@;ONIG;N?>JLI=?MMCHAI@

J?LMIH;F>;N;=IHMCMNCHAI@NB?OM?I@J?LMIH;F>;N;NI?P;FO;N?=?LN;CHJ?LMIH;F;MJ?=NML?F;NCHANI;H;NOL;F J?LMIHCHJ;LNC=OF;LNI;H;FSM?ILJL?>C=N;MJ?=NM=IH=?LHCHANB;NH;NOL;FJ?LMIHMJ?L@ILG;H=?;NQILE

?=IHIGC=MCNO;NCIHB?;FNBJ?LMIH;FJL?@?L?H=?MCHN?L?MNML?FC;<CFCNS<?B;PCIOLFI=;NCIHILGIP?G?HNMc

/?AOF;NCIH"2 IHNB?JLIN?=NCIHI@H;NOL;FJ?LMIHMQCNBL?A;L>NINB?JLI=?MMCHAI@J?LMIH;F

>;N;;H>IHNB?@L??GIP?G?HNI@MO=B>;N;;H>L?J?;FCHA!CL?=NCP?" ,')

0B;ECF;O-;MB;;H>INB?LMd"2);Q-?LMJ?=NCP?MIH)I=;NCIH!;N;-LCP;=SCH0G;LNJBIH?M;H>

&H@ILG?> IHM?HN@IL1L;HMJ;L?H=Se "OLIJ?;H!;N;-LIN?=NCIH);Q/?PC?Q

(16)

CGJILN;HN@ILFI=;NCIH>;N;NI<?J?LMIH;F>;N;1BCMQ;S;FFJLIPCMCIHMI@NB?$!-/QBC=B JLIN?=NJ?LMIH;F>;N;>IJLIN?=NJ?LMIH;FFI=;NCIH>;N;;MQ?FF

&HMBILNNB?L?;L?>C@@?L?HNNSJ?MI@J?LMIH;F>;N;FI=;NCIH>;N;<?CHAIH?I@NB?G)I=;NCIH

>;N;=IHMCMNI@>C@@?L?HN=IHN?HNM;H>?F?G?HNM<ONHIN;FF;L?J?LMIH;F>;N;4B?HNBIM?

?F?G?HNM;L?=;J;<F?I@C>?HNC@SCHA;J;LNC=OF;LJ?LMIHFI=;NCIH>;N;<?=IG?J?LMIH;F>;N;

?=;OM? I@ NB? OHCKO? ;H> >CMNCH=NCP? H;NOL? I@ FI=;NCIH >;N; NBCM L?KOCL?M MJ?=C;F

=IHMC>?L;NCIH#CAOL?MBIQMNB?CHN?LL?F;NCIH<?NQ??HFI=;NCIH>;N;;H>J?LMIH;F>;N;

#CAOL?&HN?LM?=NCIH<?NQ??HJ?LMIH;F;H>FI=;NCIH>;N;

1BCM >CMM?LN;NCIH CH>C=;N?M NB;N bFI=;NCIH JLCP;=Sc ;H> bFI=;NCIH >;N; JLCP;=Sc ;L? P?LS MCGCF;LONCNCM;FMINLO?NB;NNB?SG;SHINH?=?MM;LCFS<?NB?M;G?=IH=?JNMCH=?NB?L?;L?

>C@@?L?H=?M<?NQ??HCHNLOMCIHCHNINB?JLCP;N?MJB?L?I@;HCH>CPC>O;F;H>NB?CHN?HMCNSI@NB?

JLI=?MMCHAI@FI=;NCIH>;N;%IQ?P?LNB?>CMM?LN;NCIH@I=OM?MG;CHFSIHNB?IP?LF;JJCHA MCGCF;LCNC?MACPCHA;QC>?<?LNBNINB?>C@@?L?H=?M

)I=;NCIHJLCP;=SCM>?@CH?><SF;MN;CL/?L?M@IL>;H>#L;HE0N;D;HI;MbNB?;<CFCNSNI JL?P?HNINB?LJ;LNC?M@LIGF?;LHCHAIH?eM=OLL?HNILJ;MNFI=;NCIHc#LIGGCHILLCMEMNINB?

M?LCIOM B;T;L> I@ NL?MJ;MM NB?@N IL FIMM I@ L?JON;NCIH IL ?P?H FC@? =;H L?MOFN @LIG FIMCHA

=IHNLIFI@FI=;NCIHJLCP;=S)I=;NCIH>;N;JLCP;=SCGJFC?MNB?LCABNIL;ONBILCNSHINNIL?P?;F FI=;NCIH ;H> JL?P?HN OH;ONBILCM?> =IFF?=NCIH JLI=?MMCHA ;H> NL;HMGCMMCIH I@ J?LMIH;F IL )?>;;LACINNC;H>INB?LM?3./638/=09<:?,63-+.7383=><+>398=9869-+>398:<3@+-C"OLIJ?;H

IGGCMMCIH'/ 1?=BHC=;F/?JILNM3?LMCIH

F;MN;CL/?L?M@IL>;H>#L;HE0N;D;HId)I=;NCIH-LCP;=SCH-?LP;MCP? IGJONCHAe &"""

-?LP;MCP? IGJONCHABNNJMQQQ=F=;G;=OEU@GMJ;J?LM?L?M@IL>0N;FI=;NCIHJ>@

;==?MM?>#?<LO;LS

"F?H;0CGIH;)IB;H;H>INB?LMd-IMCNCIHCHA0?=OLCNS;H>-LCP;=SMJ?=NMeCH*;>BOM;HE;)CS;H;A?;H>

INB?LM?>M 97:</2/8=3@/?3./>9%/-?<3>C4CF?S

-?LMIH;F )I=;NCIH

!;N;

-?LMIH;F

!;N;

)I=;NCIH

!;N;

(17)

ILA;HCM;NCIH;FFI=;NCIHL?F;N?>CH@ILG;NCIH&H=IHH?=NCIHNIFI=;NCIH>;N;QB?H;J?LMIH FIM?MNB?;<CFCNSNI=IHNLIFBCMILB?LJ?LMIH;FFI=;NCIHCH@ILG;NCIHILNB;N;<CFCNSCMFCGCN?>

MIG?BIQ<S;HINB?L?HNCNSNB;NJ?LMIHeMJLCP;=S=IG?MOH>?LNBL?;N

1I<?GIL?JL?=CM?CH@ILG;NCIH;FJLCP;=S?H=IGJ;MM?M;P;LC?NSI@J?LMIH;FCH@ILG;NCIH

@;=NM ;H> =IGGOHC=;NCIH IH ; J;LNC=OF;L J?LMIH ,H? I@ NB?M? CM FI=;NCIH IL FI=;NCIH;F JLCP;=S QBC=B >?HIN?M JLCP;=S I@ CH@ILG;NCIH L?A;L>CHA NB? JBSMC=;F IL A?IAL;JBC=;F FI=;NCIHI@CH>CPC>O;FM1B?=IH=?JNI@JLCP;=SI@FI=;NCIHG?;HMNB;NJ?LMIHMMBIOF>B;P?

NB? LCABN NI G;E? NB?CL B;LGF?MM GIP?G?HNM @L??FS ;H> ;HIHSGIOMFS ON GI>?LH N?=BHIFIAC?M;L?MI>?P?FIJ?>QCNBMG;LN 134C#CNL;=E?LM;H>MI@NQ;L?QBC=B;L?

;<F?NIL?=IAHCM?@;=?M;H>MIIHNB;NNBCMNL;>CNCIH;FIONFIIEIHFI=;NCIHJLCP;=SCMHIQ CH?PCN;<FS=IGJLIGCM?>%IQ?P?LNB?LCABNNIJLCP;=SI@FI=;NCIH;H>MJ;=?MCH=FO>?M<?CHA CHMIFCNO>?;NBIG?;H>CHJLCP;N?MJ;=?M;H>L?;MIH;<FSMICHI@@C=?MILJO<FC=JF;=?MNI MIG?>?AL??1B?G;DILJ;LNI@NBCM>CMM?LN;NCIH>CM=OMM?MNB?LCABNNIJ?LMIH;FFI=;NCIH

>;N;JLCP;=S;H>FI=;NCIH>;N;JLIN?=NCIHI@CH>CPC>O;F>;N;MO<D?=NM;H>NB?L?MJIHMC<CFCNC?M I@>;N;=IHNLIFF?LM;H>JLI=?MMILMNI?HMOL?NB;NLCABN

==IL>CHANILNC=F? I@NB?$!-/;>;N;MO<D?=NCM;HC>?HNC@C;<F?H;NOL;FJ?LMIH1BCM JLIPCMCIH>?@CH?M;HC>?HNC@C;<F?H;NOL;FJ?LMIH;MbIH?QBI=;H<?C>?HNC@C?>>CL?=NFSIL CH>CL?=NFSCHJ;LNC=OF;L<SL?@?L?H=?NI;HC>?HNC@C?LMO=B;M;H;G?;HC>?HNC@C=;NCIHHOG<?L FI=;NCIH >;N; ;H IHFCH? C>?HNC@C?L IL NI IH? IL GIL? @;=NILM MJ?=C@C= NI NB? JBSMC=;F JBSMCIFIAC=;FA?H?NC=G?HN;F?=IHIGC==OFNOL;FILMI=C;FC>?HNCNSI@NB;NH;NOL;FJ?LMIHc LNC=F? >?@CH?M;>;N;=IHNLIFF?L;MbNB?H;NOL;FILF?A;FJ?LMIHJO<FC=;ONBILCNS;A?H=S ILINB?L<I>SQBC=B;FIH?ILDICHNFSQCNBINB?LM>?N?LGCH?MNB?JOLJIM?M;H>G?;HMI@NB?

JLI=?MMCHA I@ J?LMIH;F >;N;c !;N; JLI=?MMILM ;L? NB? M;G? <I>C?M QB?H NB?S JLI=?MM J?LMIH;F>;N;IHNB?>;N;=IHNLIFF?LeM<?B;F@8LN 9

1BCM>I=NIL;F>CMM?LN;NCIHCM<;M?>IHJO<FCMB?>;LNC=F?M?;=BI@QBC=BN;LA?NMIH?L?M?;L=B KO?MNCIH&HIL>?LNIG??NNB?I<D?=NCP?;MMN;N?>CHNB?L?M?;L=BKO?MNCIHMNB?L?M?;L=BN;E?M NB?MI=C?N;FN?=BHIFIAC=;F;H>A?IAL;JBC=;F=IHN?RNI@NB?"2;ML?JL?M?HNCHA;MCHAF?>CACN;F MI=C?NS FIHA QCNB >?M=LC<CHA NB? L?;FCNC?M ;H> CHP?MNCA;NCHA NB? L?;MIHCHA <?BCH> NB?

)I=;NCIH#ILOGH

4C#CCM;QCL?F?MMH?NQILECHAMSMN?GQBC=BJLIPC>?M;H&HN?LH?N=IHH?=NCIHQCNB>C@@?L?HNMJ??>

H?NQILEMOMCHAL;>CIQ;P?MQ?<IJ?>C;d4C#CQCL?F?MMH?NQILECHA e

BNNJMQQQQ?<IJ?>C;=IG1"/*44C:#CBNGF;==?MM?>#?<LO;LS

?LN';;J(IIJM;H>INB?LMdNSJIFIASI@JLCP;=Se 2HCP?LMCNSI@-?HHMSFP;HC;'IOLH;FI@

&HN?LH;NCIH;F);Q

(18)

L?;FCNC?MNB?NIJC=CM;H;FSM?>QCNBL?F?P;H=?NI;<LI;>MI=CIF?A;FIONFIIEQBC=BCHNB?

=IHN?RNI@N?=BHIFIAS;H>>CACN;FCM;NCIH;JJ?;L?>;MMI=CIN?=BHC=;FL;NCIH;FCNC?MCHNB?F?A;F

>IG;CH

1B?>CMM?LN;NCIHCM>CPC>?>CHNI@CP?=B;JN?LM

1BCM=B;JN?L&HNLI>O=NCIH CHNLI>O=?MNB?NIJC=CHA?H?L;F!?@CHCHAFI=;NCIHFI=;NCIH>;N;

;H>FI=;NCIH>;N;JLCP;=SL?P?;FMNB?CH?PCN;<F?CHN?L>CM=CJFCH;LS=IHH?=NCIHMI@NB?NIJC=

GIMNFSCHCNMF?A;F;H>N?=BHIFIAC=;F;MJ?=NM&N;FMI>CM=OMM?MP;LCIOM;MJ?=NMI@NB?LCABNNI JLCP;=S;H>>;N;JLIN?=NCIH@ILNB?CLCH;FC?H;<F?=IHH?=NCIHNIFI=;NCIH>;N;JLCP;=S B;JN?L b!?M=LCJNCIH I@ /?M?;L=B .O?MNCIHM ;H> LNC=F?Mc %;PCHA CHNLI>O=?> NB?

L?M?;L=BKO?MNCIHM;NNB?IONM?NNBCM=B;JN?L<LC?@FS>?M=LC<?MNB?L?M?;L=BKO?MNCIHM;H>NB?

;LNC=F?MNB?>CMM?LN;NCIHCM<;M?>IH;FIHAQCNBMIG?;>>CNCIH;FL?F?P;HN>CM=OMMCIH B;JN?Lb3;LCIOMMJ?=NMI@)I=;NCIH!;N;c;H>=B;JN?Lb B;FF?HA?MCH)I=;NCIH!;N;

;H> )I=;NCIH<;M?> 0?LPC=?M QCNB )?A;F LAOG?HNMc ;L? NB? =IL? I@ NB? >CMM?LN;NCIH

>?M=LC<CHA FI=;NCIH >;N; @LIG P;LCIOM ;HAF?M B;JN?L ;>>L?MM?M NB? KO?MNCIH I@ QB?H FI=;NCIH >;N; <?=IG? M?HMCNCP? >;N; ;H> NB? MIOL=?M @LIG QBC=B FI=;NCIH >;N; =;H <?

=IFF?=N?>QCNBMIG?F?A;F;H;FSMCMNNB?M;G?NCG?CN;LNC=OF;N?MNB?NBL?;NMNIFI=;NCIH

>;N;L?P?;F?><SNB?F;N?MNN?=BHIFIAC?M B;JN?L?HOH=C;N?MBIQ=B;FF?HACHACNCMNIJLIN?=N FI=;NCIH>;N;CHOMCHAFI=;NCIH<;M?>M?LPC=?MQB?NB?L;HIHSGCM;NCIHCM;J?L@?=NMIFONCIH

;H>NB?JL;=NC=?MI@G;HS=IGJ;HC?MCH=IFF?=NCHAFI=;NCIH>;N;MNB?$!-/CM;FL?;>SCH NB? FCG?FCABN CN >?M=LC<?M L?F?P;HN JLIPCMCIHM I@ NB? $!-/ NB?CL ?@@C=;=S CH JLIN?=NCHA J?LMIH;F FI=;NCIH >;N; ;H> NB? LCABNM I@ >;N; MO<D?=NM OH>?L NB? $!-/ 1B? ?-LCP;=S

!CL?=NCP?CMOH>?LL?PCMCIH@ILCHNLI>O=CHA?-LCP;=S/?AOF;NCIHQBC=BQCFF=IGJF?G?HNNB?

$!-/ 1BCM =B;JN?L ;FMI >?M=LC<?M MIG? JIMCNCP? CHCNC;NCP?M N;E?H <S CHN?LH;NCIH;F IL L?ACIH;FILA;HCM;NCIHM

B;JN?L b IH=FOMCIHc "H>M NB? >CMM?LN;NCIH QCNB MIG? ?RCMNCHA =B;FF?HA?M ;H>

>C@@C=OFNC?M&NMOAA?MNML?=IGG?H>;NCIHM>?MCAH?>NIIP?L=IG?NB?>C@@C=OFNC?M1BCM=B;JN?L

;FMIMOGG;LCM?MNB?@CH>CHAM;>OG<L;N?><SNB?;LNC=F?M;MQ?FF;MNB?L?M?;L=BQILEIP?L;FF

/4&2%*3$*1-*/"291120"$)"/%&$)/0-0(*$"-31&$43

)I=;NCIH;Q;L?H?MM CHPIFP?M HOG?LIOM ;H> BOA? N?=BHIFIAC=;F @?;NOL?M ;H> CGJFC=;NCIHM L?F;N?> NI GI<CF? >?PC=? @OH=NCIH;FCNS 1B?L? ;L? ;FMI <OMCH?MM ;H> MI=C;F ;MJ?=NM 1B?

(19)

>CMM?LN;NCIHCMN;LA?N?>;H>;LL;HA?>G;CHFS@LIG;F?A;F;H>HIHN?=BHC=;FJICHNI@PC?Q

@I=OMCHAIHJLCP;=S;H>>;N;JLIN?=NCIH<ONMIG?N?=BHC=;FCMMO?M;L?CH?PCN;<FS>?;FNQCNB 1B? NIJC= NBOM OH;PIC>;<FS <?=IG?M CHN?L>CM=CJFCH;LS L?M?;L=B QBC=B CM ;FMI OM?@OF @IL

=?LN;CH;MJ?=NMI@& 1;H>>;N;JLIN?=NCIHF;Q1B?L?M?;L=BCM@L;G?>GIMNFS@LIGNB?F?A;F

>CM=CJFCH;LSJICHNI@PC?Q<ON;NNB?M;G?NCG?N?=BHIFIAC=;FMI=C;F;H><OMCH?MM;MJ?=NM Q?L?;FMIL?F?P;HNNINB?>CM=OMMCIH"P?H@ILF?A;FL?M?;L=BIHMO=B;NIJC=;=?LN;CHF?P?F I@N?=BHIFIAC=;FOH>?LMN;H>CHACMH?=?MM;LS&HN?L?MNCHAFSBIQ?P?LNB?OM?LMI@GI<CF?

>?PC=?MQBIM?JLCP;=SCMCHKO?MNCIHG;SB;P?H?CNB?LN?=BHIFIAC=;FHILF?A;FEHIQF?>A?

1BCM >CMM?LN;NCIH ?H>?;PIOLM NI JLIPC>? NB? ;=;>?GC= ;O>C?H=? QCNB F?A;F ;H> ;MMI=C;N?>

N?=BHIFIAC=;FEHIQF?>A?CHL;CMCHA=IHM=CIOMH?MM;<IONNB?LCABNMI@GI<CF?>?PC=?OM?LM

;H>=L?;NCHA;Q;L?H?MMI@MB;LCHAJ?LMIH;FFI=;NCIHCH@ILG;NCIH

0IG?N?=BHC=;F=F;LC@C=;NCIHMQCFFB?FJQCNBNB?CH?M=;J;<F?N?=BHIFIAC=;F=IH=?JNM 1I;PIC>=IH@OMCIHCNCMJLO>?HNNIG?HNCIHNB;NIHNB?N?=BHC=;FMC>?NB?N?LGMbOM?LMc;H>

bM?LPC=?JLIPC>?LMc;L?OM?>MSHIHSGIOMFSQCNBNB?F?A;FN?LGMb>;N;MO<D?=NMc;H>b>;N;

=IHNLIFF?LMc ;H>IL b>;N; JLI=?MMILMc L?MJ?=NCP?FS FNBIOAB NB? >CMM?LN;NCIH CM ILA;HCM?>

@LIGF?A;FPC?QJICHNMCHMIG?L?MJ?=NMN?=BHC=;FN?LGMB;P?<??HOM?>NICH>C=;N?NB?M;G?

G?;HCHAM;H>NICH>C=;N?NB?N?LGMCH;A?H?L;FCM?>M?HM?<?=;OM?N?=BHC=;FH;G?M;L?<?NN?L EHIQHNINB?A?H?L;FJO<FC=&HINB?LQIL>MCHMIG?=;M?MN?=BHC=;FN?LGMQCFF<?OM?>

QB?L?NB?M?;L?GIL?@;GCFC;LNINB?A?H?L;FJO<FC=

*I<CF?>?PC=?M;L?G;HO@;=NOL?>B;L>Q;L?>?PC=?MQBC=BCH=FO>?MG;LNJBIH?M;H>N;<F?NM ILCH;<LI;>?LM?HM?F;JNIJM,H?I@NB?=IGGIH@?;NOL?MI@NB?M?>?PC=?MCMNB;N;FFI@NB?G

;L?=;J;<F?I@C>?HNC@SCHANB?=OLL?HNFI=;NCIHI@NB?>?PC=?MILOM?LMI@NB?>?PC=?M4BCF?

B;L>Q;L?=IHMNCNON?MNB?JBSMC=;FJ;LNMI@;GI<CF?>?PC=?CNM@OH=NCIHM;L?>?J?H>?HNIH

;MMILN?> MI@NQ;L? 1B? MI@NQ;L? <OCFN @IL ; J;LNC=OF;L JF;N@ILG EHIQH ;M NB? ,J?L;NCHA 0SMN?G,0 MO=B;MH>LIC>;H>C,0CMJL?CHMN;FF?>CH;GI<CF?>?PC=?1B?B;L>Q;L?

;H>,0=;H<?G;HO@;=NOL?><SNB?M;G?IL;>C@@?L?HNG;HO@;=NOL?LQB?L?>C@@?L?HNNB?

*C=B;?F%?LLG;HH;H>INB?LMd-LCP;=SCH)I=;NCIH;M?>0?LPC=?MH&HN?L>CM=CJFCH;LSJJLI;=Be 0 /&-1?>

%?LLG;HHH

H>LIC>CMIH?I@NB?GIMNJIJOF;LGI<CF?IJ?L;NCHAMSMN?GM;HHIOH=?><SNB?20<;M?>GOFNCH;NCIH;F N?=BHIFIAS=IGJ;HS$IIAF?F?R1I>>;H> BLCM;LL;=FIOABd4B;NCMH>LIC>;H>QB;NCM;HH>LIC>

JBIH?e</-97,?#?<LO;LS BNNJML?=IG<O=IGGI<CF?;LNC=F?QB;NCM;H>LIC>;H>QB;NCM;H

;H>LIC>JBIH?:*BNGF;==?MM?>#?<LO;LS

C,0CMNB?GI<CF?IJ?L;NCHAMSMN?G>?P?FIJ?><SNB?20<;M?>GOFNCH;NCIH;FN?=BHIFIAS=IGJ;HSJJF?

L;CA)FIS>d4B;N&MC,0e9>>+/9,36/ BNNJMQQQAINN;<?GI<CF?=IGQB;NCMCIM;==?MM?>

#?<LO;LS

(20)

B;L>Q;L?G;HO@;=NOL?L=;H;>DOMNNB?,0@ILNB?GI<CF?>?PC=?MNNB?M;G?NCG?GI<CF?

;JJ>?P?FIJ?LM>?P?FIJ;JJMQBC=B;L?;FMIMI@NQ;L?@IL>C@@?L?HN,0M,H?;JJ=;H;FMI MOJJILNOMCHAINB?L;JJM>?P?FIJ?><S;NBCL>J;LNSMI@NQ;L?>?P?FIJ?L#IL?R;GJF?QBCF?

OMCHA;#;=?<IIE;JJIH;MG;LNJBIH?NB?>?PC=?OM?L=;H;FMIJF;SMIG?IHFCH?A;G?MPC;

#;=?<IIEQBC=B;L?;JJM>?P?FIJ?><S;NBCL>J;LNSMI@NQ;L?>?P?FIJ?L&HNBCMQ;SNB?

B;L>Q;L?G;HO@;=NOL?L,0M;H>=IL?ILNBCL>J;LNS;JJ>?P?FIJ?LM=IHNLC<ON?NILOHHCHA

>C@@?L?HNMI@NQ;L?IH;GI<CF?>?PC=?1B?FI=;NCIH<;M?>M?LPC=?M;L??CNB?L=IL?ILNBCL>

J;LNSMI@NQ;L?1B?L?;L?H?NQILEMIL&HN?LH?NM?LPC=?MNBLIOABQBC=B>;N;=;H<?=IFF?=N?>

;H>NL;HM@?LL?><SH?NQILEIJ?L;NILMIL&HN?LH?NM?LPC=?JLIPC>?LM-?LMIH;FMG;LNJBIH?M

;H>=IGJONCHA>?PC=?MNBOM<?=IG?NB?MIOL=?I@FI=;NCIH;MQ?FF;MJLCP;=SCH@ILG;NCIH

2*6"$9"/%"4"204&$4*0//%*$"4*/(0$"4*0/"4"

2*6"$9

*;HS&HN?LH?NOM?LM;L?QILLC?>;<IONNB?JLCP;=SI@NB?CLIHFCH?;=NCPCNC?M4CNBIONA?NNCHA

=IH=L?N?;H>L?FC;<F?MIFONCIHMG;HSOM?LMB;P?;==?JN?>MIG?>?AL??I@=IGJLIGCM?CH NB?CLJLCP;=SIHNB?&HN?LH?N

1B?JOLJIM?I@NBCMM?=NCIHCMNI>?M=LC<?JLCP;=S;H>>;N;JLIN?=NCIHCHA?H?L;FFNBIOAB NBCM>I?MHINL?@?LNIFI=;NCIH>;N;JLCP;=SCNCMCGJFC?>QCNBCHNB?>?M=LCJNCIHI@JLCP;=S;H>

>;N;JLIN?=NCIHCHPIFPCHAJ?LMIH;FJLCP;=SQBC=BCH=FO>?MFI=;NCIHJLCP;=S "<3@+-C+8.+>+"<9>/->398?8./<$/6/@+8>+A=

1B?L?;L?M?P?L;FL?F;N?>=IH=?JNMI@JLCP;=SQBC=BMBIOF><?=IHMC>?L?>NI;=BC?P?JLIJ?L OH>?LMN;H>CHA 1B? bJLCP;=Sc =IH=?JN CM QC>?L;HACHA ;H> ?RNL?G?FS P;LC?> <?CHA

?HPCMCIH?>>C@@?L?HNFS@LIGMNO>SNIMNO>S-LCP;=SCM;HCGJILN;HNCMMO?<INBCHF;Q;H>

MI=C;FM=C?H=?0IG?M=BIF;LM?RJF;CHJLCP;=S@LIG;GIL;F;H>JBCFIMIJBC=;FPC?QJICHN

;H> MIG? >?JC=N CN @LIG ; F?A;F MN;H>JICHN -LCP;=S CM ; <LI;>?L HINCIH NB;N CH=FO>?M NB?

H;LLIQ?L=IH=?JNI@NB?bLCABNNIJLCP;=ScNB;NCH>C=;N?MNB??RN?HNI@JLCP;=SQBC=BL?KOCL?M F?A;F JLIN?=NCIH &H MBILN NB? LCABN NI JLCP;=S CGJFC?M ; F?A;F HINCIH I@ JLCP;=S @LIG NB?

;=;>?GC==IH=?JNO;FCM;NCIH

%?LLG;HHH

+;A;N;H

(CG;LN?F0B??B;Hd1IQ;L>;1SJIFIASI@&HN?LH?N2M?LM;H>,HFCH?-LCP;=S IH=?LHMe 1B?

&H@ILG;NCIH0I=C?NS

(IIJMH

(21)

"P?HCHNB?F?A;F>IG;CHNB?LCABNNIJLCP;=SCM?RJF;CH;<F?@LIGP;LCIOM;HAF?M1B?GIMN JIJOF;LIH?CMNB?NL;>CNCIH;FBOG;HLCABNM;JJLI;=B IH=?LH;<IONCH@ILG;NCIH;FJLCP;=S

;H>NB?JLCP;=SI@J?LMIH;F>;N;B;M<?=IG?CGJILN;HNQCNBNB?>?P?FIJG?HNI@CH@ILG;NCIH N?=BHIFIAC?M%IQ?P?L<INBL?ACG?M3/NB?BOG;HLCABNM;H>>;N;JLCP;=SJLIN?=NCIH L?ACG?M;L?OH>IO<N?>FSL?F;N?>NI?;=BINB?L&H@ILG;NCIHJLCP;=S;H>>;N;JLIN?=NCIHCH J;LNC=OF;L=;H<??RJIOH>?>;MNB?F;N?MNG;HC@?MN;NCIHI@;BOG;HLCABNM;JJLI;=BNIQ;L>M NB?LCABNNIJLCP;=S

1B?LCABNNIJLCP;=SCMJLIN?=N?>OH>?LLNC=F?I@NB?&HN?LH;NCIH;F IP?H;HNIH CPCF

;H>-IFCNC=;F/CABNM& -/ LNC=F?I@NB?2HCP?LM;F!?=F;L;NCIHI@%OG;H/CABNM 2!%/ LNC=F?I@NB?"OLIJ?;H IHP?HNCIHIH%OG;H/CABNM" %/ ;H>LNC=F?

I@ NB? B;LN?L I@ #OH>;G?HN;F /CABNM I@ NB? "OLIJ?;H 2HCIH "2 B;LN?L QBC=B MBIOF>;FMICH=FO>?JLCP;=SIHNB?&HN?LH?NLNC=F?I@NB?"2 B;LN?LJLIN?=NMNB?LCABN NI>;N;JLIN?=NCIH;MQ?FF1B?M=IJ?I@NB?JLCP;=SLCABNOH>?LNB?& -/;H>2!%/CM KOCN?<LI;>;H>A?H?L;F

&H"OLIJ?@OH>;G?HN;F;H>BOG;HLCABNM;L?JLIN?=N?>OH>?LNQICH>?J?H>?HN<ON=ILL?F;N?>

MSMN?GM@CLMNFSNB?"OLIJ?;H IHP?HNCIHIH%OG;H/CABNM" %/ ;H>CNM@CH;F;L<CN?L NB? "OLIJ?;H IOLN I@ %OG;H /CABNM " N%/ QBCF? NB? " N%/ ;>DO>C=;N?M ;FF?A?>

PCIF;NCIHMI@BOG;HLCABNML?=?CPCHA=IGJF;CHNM@LIGCH>CPC>O;FMCHNB?*?G<?L0N;N?MI@

b+IIH?MB;FF<?MO<D?=N?>NI;L<CNL;LSILOHF;Q@OFCHN?L@?L?H=?QCNBBCMJLCP;=S@;GCFSBIG?IL

=ILL?MJIH>?H=?HILNIOHF;Q@OF;NN;=EMIHBCMBIHIOL;H>L?JON;NCIH"P?LSIH?B;MNB?LCABNNINB?

JLIN?=NCIHI@NB?F;Q;A;CHMNMO=BCHN?L@?L?H=?IL;NN;=EMc

+I*;L=B

b+IIH?MB;FF<?MO<D?=N?>NI;L<CNL;LSCHN?L@?L?H=?QCNBBCMJLCP;=S@;GCFSBIG?IL=ILL?MJIH>?H=?HIL NI;NN;=EMOJIHBCMBIHIOL;H>L?JON;NCIH"P?LSIH?B;MNB?LCABNNINB?JLIN?=NCIHI@NB?F;Q;A;CHMNMO=B CHN?L@?L?H=?IL;NN;=EMc

2+$?H?L;FMM?G<FS/?MIFONCIH&&& I@!?=?G<?L

b"P?LSIH?B;MNB?LCABNNIL?MJ?=N@ILBCMJLCP;N?;H>@;GCFSFC@?BCMBIG?;H>BCM=ILL?MJIH>?H=?

1B?L?MB;FF<?HICHN?L@?L?H=?<S;JO<FC=;ONBILCNSQCNBNB??R?L=CM?I@NBCMLCABN?R=?JNMO=B;MCMCH

;==IL>;H=?QCNBNB?F;Q;H>CMH?=?MM;LSCH;>?GI=L;NC=MI=C?NSCHNB?CHN?L?MNMI@H;NCIH;FM?=OLCNSJO<FC=

M;@?NSILNB??=IHIGC=Q?FF<?CHAI@NB?=IOHNLS@ILNB?JL?P?HNCIHI@>CMIL>?LIL=LCG?@ILNB?JLIN?=NCIHI@

B?;FNBILGIL;FMIL@ILNB?JLIN?=NCIHI@NB?LCABNM;H>@L??>IGMI@INB?LMc

/IG?5&

b"P?LSIH?B;MNB?LCABNNIL?MJ?=N@ILBCMILB?LJLCP;N?;H>@;GCFSFC@?BIG?;H>=IGGOHC=;NCIHMc

,'

b"P?LSIH?B;MNB?LCABNNINB?JLIN?=NCIHI@J?LMIH;F>;N;=IH=?LHCHABCGILB?L0O=B>;N;GOMN<?

JLI=?MM?>@;CLFS@ILMJ?=C@C?>JOLJIM?M;H>IHNB?<;MCMI@NB?=IHM?HNI@NB?J?LMIH=IH=?LH?>ILMIG?INB?L F?ACNCG;N?<;MCMF;C>>IQH<SF;Q"P?LSIH?B;MNB?LCABNI@;==?MMNI>;N;QBC=BB;M<??H=IFF?=N?>

=IH=?LHCHABCGILB?L;H>NB?LCABNNIB;P?CNL?=NC@C?> IGJFC;H=?QCNBNB?M?LOF?MMB;FF<?MO<D?=NNI

=IHNLIF<S;HCH>?J?H>?HN;ONBILCNSc

(22)

NB? IOH=CFI@"OLIJ?0?=IH>FSNB? IOLNI@'OMNC=?I@NB?"OLIJ?;H2HCIH '"2 ?HMOL?M JLIN?=NCIHI@@OH>;G?HN;FBOG;HLCABNMCHNB?"2L?ACIHGIMNFS<;M?>IH"2 B;LN?L

&H NBCM L?MJ?=N CN CM CGJILN;HN NI HIN? NB? >C@@?L?H=? <;M?>38>/< +63+ IH >C@@?L?HN

=IGJ?N?H=?M<?NQ??HNB?" %/;H>"2 B;LN?L IHMC>?LCHANB?LIF?;H>JIMCNCIHCHNB?

"2NB?" %/;H>CNM" N%/<?FIHANI;F?A;FMSMN?GNB;NCM>C@@?L?HN@LIGNB?"2MSMN?GM

;H> JL;=NC=?M INB NB? " %/ ;H> NB? " N%/ ;L? G?G<?LM ;H> J;LNM I@ NB? IOH=CF I@

"OLIJ?4BCF?NB? IOH=CFI@"OLIJ?=IHMCMNMI@*?G<?L0N;N?MNB?"2B;M*?G<?L 0N;N?M

1B? "2 Q;M ?MN;<FCMB?> NI MCGJFC@S <OMCH?MM L?F;NCIHM ;GIHA *?G<?L 0N;N?M ;H> CN AL;>O;FFS;>IJN?>NB?@OH>;G?HN;FP;FO?MCH=FO>CHABOG;HLCABNMJLIN?=NCIHI@NB? IOH=CF I@"OLIJ?1B? IOH=CFI@"OLIJ?=IP?LM;AL?;N?LM=IJ?;H>;L?;@ILG;CHN;CHCHA=?LN;CH F?A;FMN;H>;L>M1B?"2L?@?LMNI=IGJF?G?HNM;H>=IIJ?L;N?MQCNBNB? IOH=CFOMCHA;

>C@@?L?HNJF;N@ILG;H>N;LA?NCHAJIFCNC=;F;H>?=IHIGC=CHN?AL;NCIH1B?"2 B;LN?LCMIH?

I@NB?JLCG;LSCHMNLOG?HNM>?MCAH?>NIJLIN?=NBOG;HLCABNMNBLIOABIONNB?"2*?G<?L 0N;N?M

MNB?L?M?;L=BCMIHJ?LMIH;FCH=FFI=;NCIH >;N;JLIN?=NCIHCMMO?MOH>?L"2F;Q<INBNB?

"2 B;LN?L;H>NB?" %/B;P?CH@FO?H=?IHNBCM>CMM?LN;NCIH;H>CNG?HNCIHM<INB;M;

<;=EALIOH>>CM=OMMCIH@ILNB?L?M?;L=B

1B?" %/CMIH?I@NB?GIMNMCAHC@C=;HN<CH>CHACHN?LH;NCIH;FF?A;FCHMNLOG?HNMCHJLIN?=NCIH I@@OH>;G?HN;FLCABNM&HMN?;>I@OMCHANB?N?LGJLCP;=SCNMLNC=F?G?HNCIHMNB?LCABNNI L?MJ?=N@ILJLCP;N?;H>@;GCFSFC@?QBC=B?R=FO>?MNB?N?LGMbBIHIOL;H>L?JON;NCIHc1B?

"OLIJ?;H IOLNI@%OG;H/CABNM" N%/ L;NC@C?>;H>M?=OL?>NB?HINCIHI@bL?MJ?=N@IL JLCP;N? FC@?c IL MCGJFS bNB? LCABN NI JLCP;=Sc CH "OLIJ? QCNB <CH>CHA ?@@?=N IH M?P?L;F I==;MCIHM 1B? " N%/ ;>IJN?> ; <LI;> IONFIIE CH CHN?LJL?NCHA LNC=F? I@ NB? " %/

LNC=F?=L?;N?M;HI<FCA;NCIHIHNB?*?G<?L0N;N?M<INBNI;<MN;CH@LIGCHN?L@?LCHAQCNB

'OFC;H?(IEINN;H> BLCMNIJB0I<INN;d1B?>CMNCH=NCIH<?NQ??HJLCP;=S;H>>;N;JLIN?=NCIHCHNB?

DOLCMJLO>?H=?I@NB? '"2;H>NB?" N%/e &HN?LH;NCIH;F!;N;-LCP;=S);Q

1B?2(CH;=B;HACHA"OLIJ?(CHAM IFF?A?)IH>IHd4B;NeMNB?>C@@?L?H=?<?NQ??HNB?"OLIJ?;H IHP?HNCIHIH%OG;H/CABNMNB?"OLIJ?;H IOLNI@%OG;H/CABNM;H>NB?"OLIJ?;H IOLNI@'OMNC=?e BNNJOE;H>?O;=OE@;=N@CAOL?MQB;NMNB?>C@@?L?H=?<?NQ??HNB??OLIJ?;H=IHP?HNCIHIHBOG;HLCABNM NB??OLIJ?;H=IOLNI@BOG;HLCABNM;H>NB??OLIJ?;H=IOLNI@DOMNC=?;==?MM?>+IP?G<?L

IOH=CFI@"OLIJ?d1B? IOH=CFI@"OLIJ?;H>NB?"OLIJ?;H2HCIH!C@@?L?HNLIF?MMB;L?>P;FO?Me BNNJMQQQ=I?CHN?HQ?<JILN;F?OLIJ?;HOHCIH;==?MM?>#?<LO;LS

(IIJMH

(23)

JLCP;N?FC@?;H>NIL?MJ?=NJLCP;N?FC@?1B?" N%/B;M>?=C>?>CHM?P?L;F=;M?MNB;NNB?

PCIF;NCIH I@ @OH>;G?HN;F LCABNM ;H> @L??>IGM CH NB? >CACN;F IL IHFCH? QILF> =;H ;FMI <?

>?N?LGCH?><S@IFFIQCHANB?JLIPCMCIHMI@NB?" %/;H>CNM-LINI=IFM*IL?JL?=CM?FSNB?

LCABNNIL?MJ?=N@ILJLCP;N?;H>@;GCFSFC@?OH>?LLNC=F?I@NB?" %/CMF?A;FFS?H@IL=?;<F?

;H> GCABN <? L?F?P;HN QB?H OH>O? CHN?L@?L?H=? QCNB IHFCH? =IGGOHC=;NCIHM I==OLM MOLP?CFF;H=? CM =IH>O=N?> CH ;H CGJLIJ?L Q;S ;H> ;==?MM =IFF?=NCIH L?N?HNCIH OM? IL

>CM=FIMOL? I@ J?LMIH;F CH=F FI=;NCIH >;N; ;L? OHF;Q@OFFS ?RJFICN?> <S N?=BHIFIAS

=IGJ;HC?MIHFCH?JF;N@ILGMILINB?L;ONBILCNC?M

LNC=F? I@NB?" %/;FFIQMCHN?L@?L?H=?QCNBNBCMLCABNIHFS@ILF?ACNCG;N?L?;MIHMIL QB?HNB;NCMbH?=?MM;LSCH;>?GI=L;NC=MI=C?NScMO=B;M@ILH;NCIH;FM?=OLCNSJO<FC=M;@?NS

@ILNB?=IOHNLSeM?=IHIGC=Q?FF<?CHA@ILJL?P?HNCHA=LCG?ILJLIN?=NCHAB?;FNBGIL;FMIL

@IL INB?LMe LCABNM ;H> @L??>IGM %IQ?P?L MIG?NCG?M CN CM >C@@C=OFN NI >?=C>? QB;N CM bH?=?MM;LSCH;>?GI=L;NC=MI=C?NSc1B?" N%/>?=F;L?>NB;NCHIL>?LNIG??NNB?H?=?MMCNS L?KOCL?G?HNNB?L?GOMN<?L?F?P;HNL?;MIH;<F?;H>MO@@C=C?HNL?;MIHM;H>JLIJILNCIH;F;H>

F?ACNCG;N?FS JOLMO?> JOLJIM?M &H ;>>CNCIH =IHMC>?LCHA CH>CPC>O;F CH=C>?HNM NB? IOLN

" N%/ ;==IL>M NB? H;NCIH;F ;ONBILCNC?M ; bG;LACH I@ ;JJL?=C;NCIHc ;FFIQCHA NB?G NI

>?N?LGCH?QB;NCMbH?=?MM;LSc;H>NB??RN?HNI@NB?JIMCNCP?I<FCA;NCIHMI@MN;N?MNI?HMOL?

L?MJ?=N@ILJLCP;N?FC@?QBC=BG;SP;LS@LIG=;M?NI=;M?

FNBIOABNB?" %/>I?MHIN=IHN;CH;M?J;L;N?JLIPCMCIHIH>;N;JLIN?=NCIHNB?" N%/

;JJFC?MLNC=F?CHP;LCIOM=;M?MQBC=B?H=IGJ;MM?MJ?LMIH;F>;N;JLIN?=NCIHQCNBCHNB?

?RJL?MMCIHI@NB?LCABNNIJLCP;=S1B?!;N;-LIN?=NCIH IHP?HNCIHCMCH@FO?H=?><SNB?

" %/;H>OM?MNB?<;MC=JLCH=CJF?MNI?RJL?MML?;>CH?MMNII<M?LP?LNC=F?I@NB?" %/

IH;ONIG;NC=>;N;JLI=?MMCHAG?;MOL?MNNB?M;G?NCG?CNCM=F?;LNB;N=;M?MILCACH;NCHA MIF?FS @LIG >;N; JLIN?=NCIH ;H> JLI=?MMCHA ;MJ?=NM ;L? HIN <IOH> NI ?RJFC=CNFS L?@?L ;H>

=IGJF?N?FS =IH@ILG NI NB? " %/ L?KOCL?G?HNM &H INB?L QIL>M CH>?J?H>?HN >;N;

+<-5B@/613?7JJHI" %/'OH? J;L;)??SAL;P?d!;N;-LIN?=NCIH -OLMO;HNNINB?/CABNNI-LCP;=SCH%OG;H/CABNM1L?;NC?Me &HN?LH;NCIH;F'IOLH;FI@);Q;H>

&H@ILG;NCIH1?=BHIFIAS

"A=2,C98+6.+8.9>2/<=@<+8-/JJHI" %/';HO;LS

"A'D?8@/<7+8CJJHI" %/0?JN?G<?L IOH=CFI@"OLIJ?"OLIJ?;H IOLN I@%OG;H/CABNM/?M?;L=B!CPCMCIH8>/<8/>-+=/6+A90>2/?<9:/+89?<>90?7+8$312>=

2J>;N?>'OH?

(IEINNH %/1/<=>/.>)3,/<1+8.!>2/<=@%A/./8JJHI" %/'OH? J;L;

SAL;P?H

(IEINNH M??;FMI'D?8@/<7+8CH

0NL;M<IOLA';HO;LS"OLIJ?;H1L?;NS0?LC?MHI

SAL;P?H

(24)

JLIN?=NCIHL?AOF;NCIHNIN;=EF?NB?CMMO?ML?F;N?>NI>;N;JLIN?=NCIH;H>JLI=?MMCHAHIQ?RCMNM

%IQ?P?L<INBQCHAMI@F;Q=IGJF?G?HNCHA?;=BINB?LCM?H=IOL;A?>

0CGCF;LNILNC=F?I@NB?" %/;LNC=F?I@NB?"2 B;LN?LJLIN?=NMNB?LCABNNIL?MJ?=N@IL JLCP;N?;H>@;GCFSFC@?CH=FO>CHABIG?;H>=IGGOHC=;NCIHM1B?"2 B;LN?LNIIE;MN?J

@ILQ;L> <S G;ECHA ; >CMNCH=N JLIPCMCIH @IL NB? JLIN?=NCIH I@ J?LMIH;F >;N; CH LNC=F?

M?J;L;N?@LIGLCABNNIJLCP;=S;MMN;N?>CHLNC=F?&HNBCMQ;SJ?LMIH;F>;N;JLIN?=NCIHCM L?=IAHCM?><SF;Q;M;MN;H>;FIH?LCABNLNC=F? I@NB?"2 B;LN?L;FMIMN;N?MNB;N J?LMIH;F>;N;=;HIHFS<?JLI=?MM?>@ILMJ?=C@C?>JOLJIM?M;H>C@NB?J?LMIHQBIM?>;N;;L?

=IH=?LH?>ACP?M=IHM?HNIL@ILINB?LF;Q@OFL?;MIHM1B?J?LMIH=IH=?LH?>B;MNB?LCABNNI

;==?MM;H>L?=NC@SNB?J?LMIH;F>;N;IHB?LBCG1B?M=IJ?I@NB??R=?JNCIHMNINB?LCABNNI

>;N;JLIN?=NCIH>?J;LNM@LIGNB?LCABNNIJLCP;=S2HFCE?JLCP;=SOMCHANB?A?H?L;FL?@?L?H=?

I@JO<FC=M?=OLCNSCMHINL?=IAHCM?>;M;MO@@C=C?HNL?;MIHNIFCGCNNB?LCABNNI>;N;JLIN?=NCIH

%IQ?P?L<INBNB?" N%/;H>NB? '"2N?H>NICHN?LJL?NNB?N?LGbJLCP;N?FC@?c<LI;>FS

=IHMC>?LNB?LCABNNI>;N;JLIN?=NCIH;M;HINB?L?RJL?MMCIHI@NB?JLCP;=SLCABN;H>L?KOCL?

L?MJ?=N@IL<INB1B? '"2;==?JNMNB?CHN?LJL?N;NCIHI@" N%/NB;NJ?LMIH;F>;N;JLIN?=NCIH

<?FIHAMNIbJLCP;N?FC@?cCH=ILJIL;NCHA;HSC>?HNC@C;<F?CH@ILG;NCIH@IL;HCH>CPC>O;F ;M?

F;QNBOM?MN;<FCMB?MNB;NOHF;Q@OF=IFF?=NCIHL?N?HNCIHOM?;H>JLI=?MMCHAI@J?LMIH;F>;N;

L?F;N?MNIJLCP;N?FC@?;H>CHN?L@?L?MQCNBNB?LCABNNIJLCP;=S%IQ?P?L" N%/HILG;FFS N?H>MNI>?FCP?LJLCP;=S=?HNL?>CHN?LJL?N;NCIHMCHNB?=;M?F;QQBCF?NB? '"2CMFCE?FSNI CHN?LJL?NNB?LCABNNIJLIN?=NCIHI@J?LMIH;F>;N;JOLMO;HNNINB?"2 B;LN?L1BOM;F?A;F

>C@@?L?H=? ?G?LA?> <?NQ??H NB? =IH=?JNM I@ JLCP;=S ;H> J?LMIH;F >;N; JLIN?=NCIH QCNB L?F?P;H=?NICH@ILG;NCIH;FM?F@>?N?LGCH;NCIHQBC=BCM@OLNB?L>CM=OMM?>CHNB?H?RNM?=NCIH J;LN@LIGNB?M?NL;>CNCIH;FCHN?LH;NCIH;F;H>L?ACIH;FF?A;F>I=OG?HNMNB?H??>@ILM?J;L;N?

>;N;JLIN?=NCIHF;QB;><??H<LIOABN;<IONQCNBNB??PIFONCIHI@N?=BHIFIAC?MFNBIOABNB?

"2 B;LN?L=IHN;CHMM?J;L;N?JLIPCMCIHIH>;N;JLIN?=NCIHQBC=BCMF?A;FFS?H@IL=?;<F?CN G?HNCIHMCHCNMI@@C=C;F?RJF;H;NCIH@ILLNC=F?NB;NNB?!;N;-LIN?=NCIH IHP?HNCIH;H>

!;N;-LIN?=NCIH!CL?=NCP?!-! I@GOMN<?@IFFIQ?>@ILCHN?LJL?NCHANBCMJ;LNC=OF;L

(IIJMH

(IEINNH

(IEINNH 'ICH?> ;M?M (965/<?8.+<5?=%-2/-5/,$+8.+<>7?>30/<>@

+8./==/8 '"2+IP?G<?L J;L;

"A7+88@%A3>D/<6+8.JJHI" %/#?<LO;LS J;L;M@;H>$9>+<?@

$97+83+JJHI" %/*;S J;L;M;H>

!CL?=NCP?" I@NB?"OLIJ?;H-;LFC;G?HN;H>I@NB? IOH=CFI@,=NI<?LIHNB?JLIN?=NCIHI@

CH>CPC>O;FMQCNBL?A;L>NINB?JLI=?MMCHAI@J?LMIH;F>;N;;H>IHNB?@L??GIP?G?HNI@MO=B>;N;,')

(25)

JLIPCMCIH +IQ QCNB NB? ?G?LA?H=? I@ NB? $!-/ CN MBIOF> L?JF;=? NB? !-! CH NB?

CHN?LJL?N;NCIHHINB?LL?;MIHNIJL?@?L"2>;N;JLIN?=NCIHF;QCHB;H>FCHA>;N;JLI=?MMCHA

;=NCPCNC?MCMNB;NCNMJLIPCMCIHM<CH><INBJO<FC=;ONBILCNC?M;H>JLCP;N?<I>C?M0CH=?F;LA?

;GIOHNMI@J?LMIH;F>;N;;L?=IFF?=N?>;H>JLI=?MM?><SG;HSJLCP;N??HNCNC?M;JJFSCHA"2

>;N;JLIN?=NCIHF;QCHNBCML?MJ?=NCM?@@C=C?HN;H>OM?@OF,HNB?INB?LB;H>NB?"2 B;LN?L JLIPCMCIHMJON;NCP?FS<CH>JO<FC=;ONBILCNC?M

*S >I=NIL;F >CMM?LN;NCIH ;LNC=OF;N?M MIG? <;MC= F?A;F CHMNLOG?HNM CH NBCM ;L?; QB?L? NB?

JLCP;=S=IH=?LHB;M;NNL;=N?>MCAHC@C=;HN;NN?HNCIHNIJ?LMIH;FCH=FFI=;NCIH >;N;=IFF?=NCIH

;H>JLI=?MMCHAG?;MOL?MCHNB?>CACN;F?HPCLIHG?HN

1B?!;N;-LIN?=NCIH!CL?=NCP?!-! Q;MNB?F?;>CHA"2>;N;JLIN?=NCIHF?A;FCHMNLOG?HN

@ILM?P?L;FS?;LM;CGCHANIB;LGIHCM?NB?>CMJ;L;N?H;NCIH;FF;QMI@NB?"2LNC=F?; I@

NB?!-!>?@CH?MbJ?LMIH;F>;N;cQBC=B;FNBIOABCN>I?MHIN?RJL?MMFSCH=FO>?FI=;NCIH>;N;

QIOF>JIN?HNC;FFSCH=FO>?CN

1;LA?NCHA;GIL?B;LGIHCM?>;H>OJ>;N?>>;N;JLIN?=NCIHF;Q@ILNB?"2*?G<?L0N;N?M NB?$!-/Q;MJLIGOFA;N?>CHNB?,@@C=C;F'IOLH;FIH*;S;H>;JJFC?M<S*;S

@I=OMCHA G;HS MCAHC@C=;HN ;H> L?=?HN ;MJ?=NM I@ >CACN;F ?HPCLIHG?HNM ;H> N?=BHIFIAC=;F

>?P?FIJG?HNM

)I=;NCIHJLCP;=SCMMO?M;L?;FMI>CM=OMM?>CHMIG?JLIPCMCIHMI@NB??-LCP;=S!CL?=NCP?

?-! ;G?H>?>CH LNC=F?= ;H>LNC=F?I@NB??-!J;LNC=OF;LFS>CM=OMMFI=;NCIH

>;N; ;H> JLI=?MMCHA NB?L?I@ 1B? ?-! ?H>?;PIOLM NI JLIN?=N J?LMIH;F >;N; CH N?F?=IGGOHC=;NCIHMH?NQILEM@ILJO<FC=FS;P;CF;<F??F?=NLIHC==IGGOHC=;NCIHMM?LPC=?M

#OLNB?L>CM=OMM?>CH B;JN?L

(IEINNH

*;L=OM"P;HMd"OLIJ?;H IOH=CF;JJLIP?M"2$?H?L;F!;N;-LIN?=NCIH/?AOF;NCIH>L;@N@CH;F;JJLIP;F G;S=IG?<S?H>I@e+>+"<9>/->398$/:9<>'OH?

BNNJQQQ>;N;JLIN?=NCIHL?JILN=IG?OLIJ?;H=IOH=CF;JJLIP?M?OA?H?L;F>;N;JLIN?=NCIH L?AOF;NCIH>L;@N@CH;F;JJLIP;FG;S=IG?<S?H>I@;==?MM?>0?JN?G<?L

!CL?=NCP?" I@NB?"OLIJ?;H-;LFC;G?HN;H>I@NB? IOH=CF=IH=?LHCHANB?JLI=?MMCHAI@

J?LMIH;F>;N;;H>NB?JLIN?=NCIHI@JLCP;=SCHNB??F?=NLIHC==IGGOHC=;NCIHMM?=NIL!CL?=NCP?IHJLCP;=S;H>

?F?=NLIHC==IGGOHC=;NCIHMIL?-LCP;=S!CL?=NCP? ,')

!CL?=NCP?" I@NB?"OLIJ?;H-;LFC;G?HN;H>I@NB? IOH=CF,')

!;HC?F!CGIPd!C@@?L?H=?M?NQ??HNB?-LCP;=S);QMCHNB?"2;H>NB?20e809=/-8=>3>?>/

';HO;LS BNNJL?MIOL=?MCH@IM?=CHMNCNON?=IG>C@@?L?H=?MJLCP;=SF;QMCH?O;H>OMAL?@;==?MM?>

#?<LO;LS

(26)

%-9:/90"<3@+-C+8.+>+"<9>/->398

&HBCMb;<MNL;=NME?F?NIHcIHJLCP;=S0N?JB?H1*;LAOFCM>?@CH?>CNNBOMb-LCP;=S;M;

QBIF?ILCHJ;LNL?JL?M?HNM=IHNLIFIP?LNL;HM;=NCIHM<?NQ??HJ?LMIHM ;H>INB?LM NB?

OFNCG;N?;CGI@QBC=BCMNI?HB;H=?;ONIHIGS;H>ILNIGCHCGCT?POFH?L;<CFCNSc

NP;LCIOMNCG?MM=BIF;LMB;P?=F;MMC@C?>JLCP;=SCHNB?CLIQHQ;SM#ILNB?JOLJIM?I@NB?

NIJC= NBCM >CMM?LN;NCIH H;LLIQ?> CN NI NB? JLCP;=S I@ J?LMIH;F >;N; ;H> J?LMIH;F

=IGGOHC=;NCIHPC;NB?&HN?LH?N-LCP;=SI@J?LMIH;F>;N;=;H;FMI<?CHN?LJL?N?>;MJLIN?=NCIH I@J?LMIH;F>;N;ILJ?LMIH;F>;N;JLIN?=NCIHCHNB?=OLL?HN>CACN;FCM?>QILF>;H>J?LMIH;F

=IGGOHC=;NCIH PC; NB? &HN?LH?N L?F;N?M =FIM?FS NI CH@ILG;NCIH;F JLCP;=S &H NBCM L?A;L>

OH;ONBILCM?>;==?MM=IFF?=NCIH;H>JLI=?MMCHAI@J?LMIH;F>;N;;L?CHKO?MNCIHFFNB?M?

@;=NILM;L?L?F?P;HNCHNBCM>CMM?LN;NCIH

4B?L?;MCHNB?!-!NB?LCABNNIJLCP;=S;NNL;=N?>J;LNC=OF;L;NN?HNCIHCNCMCHN?L?MNCHANB;N NB?$!-/>I?MHINOM?NB?N?LGbJLCP;=ScL;NB?L=IHMCMN?HNFSG?HNCIHCHANB?N?LGb>;N;

JLIN?=NCIHc

-LCP;=S ;H> >;N; JLIN?=NCIH ;L? >C@@?L?HNFS OH>?LMNII> ;H> ?RJF;CH?> NBLIOAB F?A;F JLIPCMCIHMCHP;LCIOMJ;LNMI@NB?QILF>0CH=?NB?G;DILGOFNCH;NCIH;FN?=BHIFIAS=IGJ;HC?M

;H>NB?CLIHFCH?M?LPC=?MILCACH;N?>CHNB?20MIG?L?F?P;HN>CM=OMMCIHCHL?F;NCIHNINB?

20NIIEJF;=?CHMIG?J;LNMI@NB?L?M?;L=BQILEQB?HNB?L?CM;=IHH?=NCIHNINB?"2&H NB?20NB?N?LGb>;N;JLCP;=ScCM;FMIOM?>A?H?L;FFSQBC=BCHNB?"2CH>C=;N?Mb>;N;

JLIN?=NCIHc0CH=?NB?JL?M?HN>CMM?LN;NCIH;H>;LNC=F?M@IFFIQFCN?L;NOL?<S<INB"2;H>20

;ONBILMNB?N?LGMb>;N;JLCP;=Sc;H>b>;N;JLIN?=NCIHc;L?OM?>;MMSHIHSGIOMFS

IHMC>?LCHANB?L?M?;L=B;L?;@ILNBCMNIJC=NB?JLCG?>C@@?L?H=?<?NQ??HNB?20;H>NB?

"2CMNB;NJLCP;=S;H>>;N;JLIN?=NCIH;L?HIN?RJFC=CNFSCH=FO>?>CHNB?20=IHMNCNONCIH&H

=IHNL;MNNB?"2=IHMC>?LMJLCP;=S;H>>;N;JLIN?=NCIH;M@OH>;G?HN;FBOG;HLCABNMQCNB

=IHMNCNONCIH;FJLIN?=NCIH;H>=IGJL?B?HMCP?F;QQBC=BCMF?A;FFS?H@IL=?;<F?&H;>>CNCIH QBCF? NB? "2 B;M CHCNC;N?> ; MCHAF? L?AOF;NCIH NB? $!-/ @IL JLIN?=NCHA J?LMIH;F >;N;

JLCP;=S;H>>;N;JLIN?=NCIHCMMO?M;L?B;H>F?><SM?P?L;F@?>?L;F;H>MN;N?F;QMCHNB?20 CHMN?;>I@B;PCHA;MCHAF?F;Q1B?20=IHMNCNONCIHH?P?LNB?F?MM=IHMC>?LMJLCP;=S;M;

#IOLNBG?H>G?HNLCABN0IG?IF>F;QMMO=B;MNB?"F?=NLIHC= IGGOHC=;NCIHM-LCP;=S

0N?JB?H1*;LAOFCMd IH=?JNCIHMI@-LCP;=S OLL?HN0N;NOM;H>+?RN0N?JMe 'IOLH;FI@

0I=C;F&MMO?M

b1B?LCABNI@NB?J?IJF?NI<?M?=OL?CHNB?CLJ?LMIHMBIOM?MJ;J?LM;H>?@@?=NM;A;CHMNOHL?;MIH;<F?

M?;L=B?M;H>M?CTOL?MMB;FFHIN<?PCIF;N?>;H>HIQ;LL;HNMMB;FFCMMO?<ONOJIHJLI<;<F?=;OM?MOJJILN?>

(27)

=N I@ ;H> NB? IGGOHC=;NCIHM =N I@ MNCFF AIP?LH FI=;NCIH >;N; L?F;N?>

>CMJON?M CH NB? 20 ;FNBIOAB QB?NB?L NB?M? IF> F;QM =;H ;JJLIJLC;N?FS L?MIFP? L?=?HN FI=;NCIH>;N;JLCP;=S;LAOG?HNMQCNBL?A;L>NIGI<CF?;JJM;H>&HN?LH?NOM;A?CM;>C@@?L?HN NIJC=%IQ?P?LMIG?>L;@N<CFFM>?MCAH?>NIAIP?LHJLCP;=S;H>FI=;NCIH>;N;;L?;FL?;>S OH>?L>CM=OMMCIHCHNB?201B?20N;E?M;NIN;FFS>C@@?L?HN;JJLI;=B;H>J?LMIH;F>;N;

JLIN?=NCIHG;NN?LMG;CHFS;NNL;=N;NN?HNCIH<SG;LE?N@IL=?MNB?L?

4B?NB?L NB? LCABN NI J?LMIH;F >;N; JLIN?=NCIH L?;FFS CM ; >CMNCH=N LCABN QCNB ;>>CNCIH;F JLIN?=NCIHILMCGJFSCM;J;LNI@NB?A?H?L;FLCABNNIJLCP;=SCMMNCFF;J?LJF?RCHAKO?MNCIH&H

;==IL>;H=?QCNBNB?Q;SMNB?" %/;H>"2 B;LN?L=IHMC>?LJ?LMIH;F>;N;JLIN?=NCIHNB?

H;NCIH;F=IHMNCNONCIHMI@GIMN"2=IOHNLC?MJLIN?=NNB?LCABNNIJLIN?=NCIHI@J?LMIH;F>;N;

QCNB=IHMNCNONCIH;FAO;L;HN??M-LIPC>CHAMO=B=IHMNCNONCIH;FJLIN?=NCIHQCNBNB?LCABNNI J?LMIH;F>;N;JLIN?=NCIH;M;HCH>CPC>O;FLCABNCGJFC?MNB;NCNCM;@OH>;G?HN;FBOG;HLCABN CH CNM?F@ &N CM CGJILN;HN NI HIN? NB;N ;FNBIOAB JLCP;=S JL?P;CFM CH NB? J?LMIH;F >;N;

JLIN?=NCIH L?ACG? JLCP;=S CM HIN NB? IHFS ;H> =IHMN;HN @I=OM I@ >;N; JLIN?=NCIH <?=;OM?

MIG?J?LMIH;F>;N;>IHINL?F;N?NIJLCP;N?FC@?%IQ?P?LNB;N>C@@?L?H=?CMP?LSMFCABN;H>

HIN;FF"2=IOHNLC?ML?=IAHCM?CN1B?;=NO;FCNSCMNB;N>;N;JLIN?=NCIH;H>NB?LCABNNIJLCP;=S

;L? ?CNB?L =IHMC>?L?> OH>?L NB? M;G? JLIPCMCIH IL ?P?H C@ QCNB M?J;L;N? JLIPCMCIHM <ON OFNCG;N?FS<INB<?FIHANINB?<LI;>?LJLCP;=SLCABNM=;N;FIAO?1BCMOHCKO?JIMCNCIHI@NB?

<SI;NBIL;@@CLG;NCIH;H>J;LNC=OF;LFS>?M=LC<CHANB?JF;=?NI<?M?;L=B?>;H>NB?J?LMIHMILNBCHAMNI<?

M?CT?>c

" - 20 ]BNNJMCNIDJAIPJLCP;=SFC<?LNS;ONBILCNC?MMN;NON?M;==?MM?>

#?<LO;LS

20 ]?NM?KBNNJMCNIDJAIP-LCP;=S)C<?LNS;ONBILCNC?MMN;NON?M;==?MM?>#?<LO;LS

0??@IL?R;GJF?$?IFI=;NCIH-LCP;=S)?ACMF;NCIH$-0$,3

BNNJMQQQAJMAIPJIFC=SF?ACMF;NCIHAJM;=N;==?MM?>#?<LO;LS%?;NB?LOLHMd)?A;F

$OC>?FCH?M#IL1B?2M?,@)I=;NCIH!;N;,H1B?4?<e%7+=2381+1+D38/*;L=B

BNNJMQQQMG;MBCHAG;A;TCH?=IGFI=;NCIH>;N;Q?<>?P?FIJG?HN;H>NB?F;Q;==?MM?>

#?<LO;LS

!CGIPH !L#L;HTCME;I?BG;H>INB?LMd=IGJ;LCMIH<?NQ??H20;H>"2>;N;JLIN?=NCIH F?ACMF;NCIH@ILF;Q?H@IL=?G?HNJOLJIM?Me -IFC=S!?J;LNG?HN CNCT?HM/CABNM;H> IHMNCNONCIH;F

@@;CLM"OLIJ?;H-;LFC;G?HN

(IEINNH

"A0?=NCIHI@NB? IHMNCNONCIHI@#CHF;H>8OHI@@C=C;FNL;HMF;NCIH'OH?;G?H>G?HNM OJNICH=FO>?> 9>?=F;L?MNB?LCABNNIJLCP;=SQBC=BCH=FO>?MJLIN?=NCIHI@J?LMIH;F>;N;;M;

<;MC=LCABN;H>FC<?LNSb"P?LSIH?MJLCP;N?FC@?BIHIOL;H>NB?M;H=NCNSI@NB?BIG?;L?AO;L;HN??>*IL?

>?N;CF?>JLIPCMCIHMIHNB?JLIN?=NCIHI@J?LMIH;F>;N;;L?F;C>>IQH<S;H=N

1B?M?=L?=SI@=ILL?MJIH>?H=?N?F?JBIHS;H>INB?L=IH@C>?HNC;F=IGGOHC=;NCIHMCMCHPCIF;<F?cH

?R=?JNCIHNINBCMLCABNGCABN<?J?LGCNN?>IHFSCHFCGCN?>=CL=OGMN;H=?M@IL?R;GJF?@ILAO;L;HN??CHA

@OH>;G?HN;FLCABNM;H>FC<?LNC?MILCHP?MNCA;NCHA=LCG?M

0CGCF;LFSLNC=F?I@NB?b;MC=);Q@ILNB?#?>?L;F/?JO<FC=I@$?LG;HScQBC=BCM=IHMC>?L?>;MNB?

=IHMNCNONCIHI@NB?#?>?L;F/?JO<FC=I@$?LG;HSG?HNCIHMJLCP;=SI@=ILL?MJIH>?H=?JIMNM;H>

N?F?=IGGOHC=;NCIHMb 1B?JLCP;=SI@=ILL?MJIH>?H=?JIMNM;H>N?F?=IGGOHC=;NCIHMMB;FF<?CHPCIF;<F?

/?MNLC=NCIHMG;S<?IL>?L?>IHFSJOLMO;HNNI;F;Qc

(28)

=IH=?JNJ?LMIH;F>;N;JLIN?=NCIHCH>C=;N?MNB;NNB?=IHMNCNONCIH;F=IP?L;A?I@>;N;JLIN?=NCIH CM =FIM?FS L?F;N?> NI NB? LCABN NI JLCP;=S >?P?FIJCHA ; >CMNCH=N @ILG I@ JLCP;=S NB;N CM CH@ILG;NCIH;FJLCP;=S

NNB?M;G?NCG?CNCMNLO?NB;NCHMJCN?I@MCAHC@C=;HNIP?LF;J<?NQ??HLCABNNIJLCP;=S;H>

>;N;JLIN?=NCIHNB?S;L?HINC>?HNC=;F;H>NB?L?;L?>C@@?L?H=?M<?NQ??HNB?M=IJ?I@?;=B LCABN4BCF?;==IL>CHANILNC=F? I@NB?$!-/J?LMIH;F>;N;JLIN?=NCIHCML?F;N?>NI;HS CH@ILG;NCIH=IH=?LHCHA;HC>?HNC@C?>ILC>?HNC@C;<F?H;NOL;FJ?LMIHJLCP;=SCM=IH=?LH?>QCNB JLCP;N?FC@?NB;N>I?MHIN;FQ;SMCHPIFP?NB?C>?HNC@C;<CFCNSI@;J?LMIH&HNBCML?MJ?=N>;N;

JLIN?=NCIH=IP?LM;<LI;>?LM=IJ?NB;HNB;NI@JLCP;=SONCH;HINB?LL?MJ?=NJLCP;=S=IP?LM

;<LI;>?LM=IJ?MCH=?CNCH=FO>?M<INBH;NOL;F;H>F?A;FJ?LMIHMQBCF?;==IL>CHANI$!-/

;H>!-!>;N;JLIN?=NCIHIHFSCH=FO>?MH;NOL;FJ?LMIHM

1B?GI>?LHQILF>CM?RNL?G?FSN?=BHIFIAS@I=OM?>;H>&HN?LH?N<;M?>&HG;HS>?P?FIJ?>

=IOHNLC?M ;==?MM NI NB? &HN?LH?N CM =IHMC>?L?> ;M ; <;MC= BOG;H LCABN 1B? &HN?LH?N B;M

<?=IG?J;LN;H>J;L=?FI@NB?CL>;CFSFCP?M;H><?=;OM?I@MO=BI<PCIOM>?J?H>?H=?IHNB?

&HN?LH?N JLCP;=S QCNB L?A;L> NI &HN?LH?N ;=NCPCNC?M CM GIMNFS >CM=OMM?> L?=?HNFS &H NBCM

>CACN;FCM?>;H>&HN?LH?N=IHH?=N?>QILF>NB?JLCP;=S=IH=?LH=IGJLCM?M;ONIG;N?>Q;SMI@

MB;LCHA>;N;;H>CG;A?M;H>?@@ILNF?MMNBCL>J;LNS;==?MMNIJ?LMIH;F>;N;QCNBIONNB?>;N;

MO<D?=NMeEHIQF?>A?H>?HMOLCHANB?LCABNNI&HN?LH?NJLCP;=SGIL?MJ?=C@C=;FFSJLIN?=NCIH I@J?LMIH;F>;N;MOAA?MNMNB?LCABNNI?R?L=CM?MO<MN;HNC;F=IHNLIFIP?LJ?LMIH;F>;N;<SNB?

>;N;MO<D?=NM

!?P?FIJG?HNI@NBCMMJ?=C;FNSJ?I@JLCP;=SJLIN?=NCIHH?=?MMCN;N?M;=ILL?F;N?>MC>?NB;NCM JLCP;=SJLIN?=NCIHCH=IGJON?LMSMN?GMQBC=BCH=FO>?MG;LNJBIH?MN;<F?NM;H>;HSNSJ?I@

=IGJON?L &H MIG? "OLIJ?;H =IOHNLC?M FCE? $?LG;HS NB? b@OH>;G?HN;F LCABN NI NB?

=IH@C>?HNC;FCNS;H>CHN?ALCNSI@CH@ILG;NCIHN?=BHIFIASMSMN?GMcIL=IGJON?LMSMN?GMA?N

=IHMNCNONCIH;F JLIN?=NCIH 0?=L?N CHP?MNCA;NCIHM GIHCNILCHA IHFCH? ;=NCPCNC?M PC; J?LMIH;F

(IIJMH

(IEINNH

(IIJMH

1B?$?LG;H#?>?L;F IHMNCNONCIH;F IOLNOH>?MP?L@;MMOHAMA?LC=BN >?FCP?L?>;F;H>G;LELOFCHAIH

#?<LO;LS3?L@$+'4 &N@IOH>JLIPCMCIHMI@NB?+ILNB/BCH?4?MNJB;FC;H=NIHNB?

-LIN?=NCIHI@NB? IHMNCNONCIHOH=IHMNCNONCIH;FQBC=B;ONBILCM?>NB?M?=L?NM?LPC=?MI@NB?AIP?LHG?HNNI GIHCNILIHFCH?;=NCPCNC?M;H>=IH>O=NMOLP?CFF;H=?I@CHN?LH?N=IGGOHC=;NCIHM;H>=IGJON?LMSMN?GM1B?

=IOLN;FMIB?F>NB;NLNC=F?I@NB?b;MC=);Q@ILNB?#?>?L;F/?JO<FC=I@$?LG;HScIL$?LG;H IHMNCNONCIH$LOH>A?M?NT NI<?;H;JJFC=;<F?=IHMNCNONCIH;FLCABNQBC=BAO;L;HN??MJLCP;=SI@

N?F?=IGGOHC=;NCIHMCH=FO>CHAIHFCH?=IGGOHC=;NCIHM'[LAF?R;H>?L-;OFd$?LG;H IHMNCNONCIH;F IOLN

=L?;N?M;H?Q@OH>;G?HN;Fb&1-LCP;=Sc/CABNe3<.3<.0?JN?G<?L

BNNJMQQQNQI<CL>M=IG?HH?QM;LNC=F?MA?LG;H=IHMNCNONCIH;F=IOLN=L?;N?M;H?Q@OH>;G?HN;F

Viittaukset

LIITTYVÄT TIEDOSTOT

To summarize, existing privacy solutions are based on voluntary use, user control and consent, crypto- graphic data storage, minimum data collection, limited data usage,

Article III: Jenna Lindqvist, ‘New challenges to personal data processing agreements: is the GDPR fit to deal with contract, accountability and liability in a world of the

Drones, RPAS, data protection, privacy, surveillance, emerging technology, European law, Eu- ropean Convention on Human Rights, Data Protection Directive, general data protection

Can the mobile phone become a ubiquitous personal assistant that facilitates identity proofs and secure mobile payments, at the same time preserving its user’s privacy.. What are

Toistaiseksi yritykset ovat perustaneet toimintansa siihen, että käyttäjät ovat huolettomia heihin liitetyn tiedon kaupallistamisessa, mutta suunta voi muuttua

Experience of Ubiquitous Computing Technology Driven Mobile Commerce in Africa: Impact of Usability, Privacy, Trust, and Reputation Concern.. Olaleye,

Jos valinnanvapaus halutaan ulottaa myös yksinäisille ja vähävaraisille vanhuksille, voidaan ennustaa, että esimerkiksi julkisten edunvalvojien apu sosiaali- ja.. 40

The CCPA has many similarities with GDPR in Europe, but one of the main differences is that the consumers have the right to know to whom their data is sold